Echocardiography Management for Patients Requiring Care for Non-Cardiac Surgery
| Status: | Completed |
|---|---|
| Conditions: | Peripheral Vascular Disease |
| Therapuetic Areas: | Cardiology / Vascular Diseases |
| Healthy: | No |
| Age Range: | 19 - Any |
| Updated: | 4/2/2016 |
| Start Date: | June 2010 |
| End Date: | February 2013 |
| Contact: | Tara R Brakke, M.D. |
| Email: | tbrakke@unmc.edu |
| Phone: | (402) 559-4081 |
Echocardiography-Guided Hemodynamic Management Strategy for Patients Requiring Perioperative Care for Non-Cardiac Surgery
The growing population of University of Nebraska Medical Center patients with heart failure
combined with the increasing number of surgical procedures performed each year supports the
need for a critical analysis of how to most appropriately manage these patients during the
perioperative period, especially for non-cardiac surgery. Echo-guided hemodynamic management
(EGHEM) is the use of echocardiography data to normalize and/or optimize in real-time,
cardiac output and ventricular filling pressures in the perioperative period for non-cardiac
surgical cases. The purpose of this study is to test the hypothesis that EGHEM compared to
standard management practices will result in a reduced length of hospital stay in the
noncardiac surgery population. The primary goal of health care providers for patients
requiring anesthetic care, perioperative care, or critical care is ensuring the adequacy of
the patient's circulatory function by optimizing cardiac output and ventricular filling
pressure. Currently, the use of the ECG monitor and systemic blood pressure are the standard
of care for assessing circulatory function. However, those data cannot provide accurate
information on cardiac output and ventricular filling pressure for patients with
cardiovascular risk factors and/or comorbidities. As a result, managing the hemodynamic
parameters of these patients, as well as their intravenous fluid needs and resuscitation
strategy, we hypothesize that using traditional approaches may lead to significant volume
overload and post-operative cardiovascular complications and morbidity. In this study we
propose an EGHEM strategy that incorporates standard echocardiography generated data points
in addition to the systemic blood pressure and ECG signal to assess, manage, modify and
optimize patient cardiac preload, afterload, heart rate and contractility in the
perioperative period. Based on our initial observations and preliminary data using the EGHEM
approach, we hypothesize that we can demonstrate a significant decrease in hospital length
of stay and an overall decrease in perioperative morbidity at 30 days in the non-cardiac
surgery population using EGHEM compared to standard practices. In this proposal we have
designed a single center, prospective, randomized clinical trial to test our hypothesis.
combined with the increasing number of surgical procedures performed each year supports the
need for a critical analysis of how to most appropriately manage these patients during the
perioperative period, especially for non-cardiac surgery. Echo-guided hemodynamic management
(EGHEM) is the use of echocardiography data to normalize and/or optimize in real-time,
cardiac output and ventricular filling pressures in the perioperative period for non-cardiac
surgical cases. The purpose of this study is to test the hypothesis that EGHEM compared to
standard management practices will result in a reduced length of hospital stay in the
noncardiac surgery population. The primary goal of health care providers for patients
requiring anesthetic care, perioperative care, or critical care is ensuring the adequacy of
the patient's circulatory function by optimizing cardiac output and ventricular filling
pressure. Currently, the use of the ECG monitor and systemic blood pressure are the standard
of care for assessing circulatory function. However, those data cannot provide accurate
information on cardiac output and ventricular filling pressure for patients with
cardiovascular risk factors and/or comorbidities. As a result, managing the hemodynamic
parameters of these patients, as well as their intravenous fluid needs and resuscitation
strategy, we hypothesize that using traditional approaches may lead to significant volume
overload and post-operative cardiovascular complications and morbidity. In this study we
propose an EGHEM strategy that incorporates standard echocardiography generated data points
in addition to the systemic blood pressure and ECG signal to assess, manage, modify and
optimize patient cardiac preload, afterload, heart rate and contractility in the
perioperative period. Based on our initial observations and preliminary data using the EGHEM
approach, we hypothesize that we can demonstrate a significant decrease in hospital length
of stay and an overall decrease in perioperative morbidity at 30 days in the non-cardiac
surgery population using EGHEM compared to standard practices. In this proposal we have
designed a single center, prospective, randomized clinical trial to test our hypothesis.
Step 1: Patient selection
The first step in the EGHEM/EGAM process is appropriate patient selection. Patients who have
any of the following cardiovascular risk factors and/or comorbidities and are scheduled for
a non-cardiac surgery are candidates for EGHEM/EGAM:
1. Urology/gynecology/General surgical patient
2. Non-cardiac surgical population
3. age 65 years or older, OR 19 years or older and one of the following risk factors:
1. Hypertension (HTN)
2. Diabetes
3. Obesity (body mass index [BMI] >35)
4. Renal insufficiency
5. Tobacco usage
6. Hypercholesterolemia
7. Sleep apnea/heavy snoring at night
8. Clinical diagnosis of CHF as defined by:
- Dyspnea on exertion
- Paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea
- Orthopnea
- Elevated jugular venous pressure
- Pulmonary rales
- Third heart sound
- Cardiomegaly or pulmonary edema on chest x-ray
- Peripheral edema
- Hepatomegaly
- Pleural effusion
9. Palpitations/irregular heart beats
10. Chest pain at rest and or exercise
11. Murmur on examination
12. Known coronary artery disease (CAD)/stents/coronary artery bypass graft (CABG)
13. Known valvular disease
14. Known stroke or transient ischemic attacks (TIA) Standard Medical Care Step 2:
Pre-op assessment
Step 2 in the EGAM process involves a bedside, transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) pre-op
assessment. The pre-op TTE should be performed by one of the co-investigators, and take less
than 10 minutes to complete. The information acquired by TTE during the pre-op assessment
should include the following five evaluations, in order of importance:
1. Cardiac output on the left side of the heart using spectral Doppler measurements;
1. Left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) velocity time integral (VTI)
2. Heart rate
2. Filling pressures on the left side of the heart using spectral Doppler measurements;
1. The pulmonary venous flow pattern defined as co-dominant, systolic dominant or
diastolic dominant
2. The mitral inflow pattern defined as normal, impaired relaxation, pseudonormal or
restrictive
3. The E/e' ratio of velocities
3. Mitral valve structure and function;
4. Aortic valve structure and function; and
5. Biventricular contractility.
These evaluations are performed using the following TTE views:
A. Parasternal (PS) window: With the patient in the left lateral decubitus position, the TTE
probe is placed on the 3rd left intercostal space next to the sternum; the light on the
probe should be directed toward the patient's right shoulder. The 2-dimensional image of the
long axis (LAX) should be acquired first. In this view, the following are evaluated:
- Color Doppler on aortic valve (AV) and mitral valve (MV)
- E-point septal separation (EPSS) To evaluate the PS short axis (SAX), the probe should
be rotated clockwise 60 degrees. The 2-dimensional view should be obtained at the
mid-papillary level.
B. Apical window: With the patient in the same left, lateral, decubitus position, the probe
is placed between the 5th and 6th intercostal space on the left side, close to the nipple
line. The light on the probe should be directed toward the floor or the bed for the
4-chamber view. The following assessments should be performed in the 4-chamber view:
- Two-dimensional image;
- Pulsed-wave (PW) Doppler in the right upper pulmonary vein;
- PW Doppler at the tip of the MV;
- PW Doppler on the MV annulus for tissue Doppler;
- Color Doppler on the tricuspid valve (TV) and MV if necessary based on the PS LAX
window.
For the apical LAX, the probe should be rotated counterclockwise so that the light is
directed toward the patient's right shoulder. In the LAX view, velocity time integrals
(VTIs) using PW in the left ventricular outflow track (LVOT) and continuous wave (CW) at the
level of the AV should be acquired.
C. Subcostal window: With the patient supine, the TTE probe is placed under the right costal
ridge and directed toward the heart. The light should be directed toward the sonographer
(toward the patient's left) to assess the 4-chamber view.
For the subcostal inferior vena cava (IVC) view, the probe should be slightly rotated
counterclockwise until the IVC can be assessed.
Standard Medical Care Step 3: Management strategies Step 3 in the EGHEM/EGAM process is to
define patient management strategies based on the pre-op TTE assessment. The main goals of
patient management are to maintain normal cardiac output and filling pressure. Primary and
secondary findings and the associated EGAM strategies to achieve these goals are outlined in
Table 1 and Table 2, respectively.
Table 1: Primary findings and associated management strategy to maintain normal cardiac
output and filling pressure.
Echo-Generated Findings EGHEM/EGAM Strategy Cardiac output status Filling pressure status
Normal High Preload reduction Low Normal Afterload reduction Low High Afterload and preload
reduction High High Preload reduction High Normal or low Increase preload
Table 2: Secondary findings and associated management strategy to optimize patient
management.
Echo-Generated Finding EGHEM/EGAM Strategy Filling Pressure Other High Aortic stenosis
Preload reduction Normal Aortic stenosis Safe for afterload reduction
- Mitral regurgitation Afterload reduction
- Low contractility Inotropic support
- Suspected or confirmed CAD Maintain heart rate in the 50 - 60 bpm range RV volume
overload Preload reduction RV pressure overload Pulmonary afterload reduction Standard
Medical Care Step 4: Ongoing intra-operative assessment Based on the appropriate EGAM
strategy defined in Step 3, either TEE or TTE should be used during the surgical
procedure for the ongoing patient assessment every 15 to 20 minutes. The PI or
Secondary Investigator will determine whether a TEE or TTE should be conducted
intra-operatively. The results of these tests will be used for research purposes.
During surgery: fluid administration, afterload adjustments, and supported
contractility can be implemented to optimize patient management. It is difficult to
assess cardiac output with the current standard medical care without invasive
monitoring. There is minimal risk if the physician gets distracted by the
echocardiogram or the algorithm of the study however it is unlikely this tool would be
a distraction to the physician as it is monitoring the patient.
The randomization is very thought through due to the fact that any
Urology/Gynecology/General surgical patient will be consented for the study so there for no
specific demographics are being recruited other than what is in the inclusion criteria.
Currently for the UNMC Urology/Gynecology surgical patients the distribution lies such that
47 percent are men and 53 percent are women.
The first step in the EGHEM/EGAM process is appropriate patient selection. Patients who have
any of the following cardiovascular risk factors and/or comorbidities and are scheduled for
a non-cardiac surgery are candidates for EGHEM/EGAM:
1. Urology/gynecology/General surgical patient
2. Non-cardiac surgical population
3. age 65 years or older, OR 19 years or older and one of the following risk factors:
1. Hypertension (HTN)
2. Diabetes
3. Obesity (body mass index [BMI] >35)
4. Renal insufficiency
5. Tobacco usage
6. Hypercholesterolemia
7. Sleep apnea/heavy snoring at night
8. Clinical diagnosis of CHF as defined by:
- Dyspnea on exertion
- Paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea
- Orthopnea
- Elevated jugular venous pressure
- Pulmonary rales
- Third heart sound
- Cardiomegaly or pulmonary edema on chest x-ray
- Peripheral edema
- Hepatomegaly
- Pleural effusion
9. Palpitations/irregular heart beats
10. Chest pain at rest and or exercise
11. Murmur on examination
12. Known coronary artery disease (CAD)/stents/coronary artery bypass graft (CABG)
13. Known valvular disease
14. Known stroke or transient ischemic attacks (TIA) Standard Medical Care Step 2:
Pre-op assessment
Step 2 in the EGAM process involves a bedside, transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) pre-op
assessment. The pre-op TTE should be performed by one of the co-investigators, and take less
than 10 minutes to complete. The information acquired by TTE during the pre-op assessment
should include the following five evaluations, in order of importance:
1. Cardiac output on the left side of the heart using spectral Doppler measurements;
1. Left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) velocity time integral (VTI)
2. Heart rate
2. Filling pressures on the left side of the heart using spectral Doppler measurements;
1. The pulmonary venous flow pattern defined as co-dominant, systolic dominant or
diastolic dominant
2. The mitral inflow pattern defined as normal, impaired relaxation, pseudonormal or
restrictive
3. The E/e' ratio of velocities
3. Mitral valve structure and function;
4. Aortic valve structure and function; and
5. Biventricular contractility.
These evaluations are performed using the following TTE views:
A. Parasternal (PS) window: With the patient in the left lateral decubitus position, the TTE
probe is placed on the 3rd left intercostal space next to the sternum; the light on the
probe should be directed toward the patient's right shoulder. The 2-dimensional image of the
long axis (LAX) should be acquired first. In this view, the following are evaluated:
- Color Doppler on aortic valve (AV) and mitral valve (MV)
- E-point septal separation (EPSS) To evaluate the PS short axis (SAX), the probe should
be rotated clockwise 60 degrees. The 2-dimensional view should be obtained at the
mid-papillary level.
B. Apical window: With the patient in the same left, lateral, decubitus position, the probe
is placed between the 5th and 6th intercostal space on the left side, close to the nipple
line. The light on the probe should be directed toward the floor or the bed for the
4-chamber view. The following assessments should be performed in the 4-chamber view:
- Two-dimensional image;
- Pulsed-wave (PW) Doppler in the right upper pulmonary vein;
- PW Doppler at the tip of the MV;
- PW Doppler on the MV annulus for tissue Doppler;
- Color Doppler on the tricuspid valve (TV) and MV if necessary based on the PS LAX
window.
For the apical LAX, the probe should be rotated counterclockwise so that the light is
directed toward the patient's right shoulder. In the LAX view, velocity time integrals
(VTIs) using PW in the left ventricular outflow track (LVOT) and continuous wave (CW) at the
level of the AV should be acquired.
C. Subcostal window: With the patient supine, the TTE probe is placed under the right costal
ridge and directed toward the heart. The light should be directed toward the sonographer
(toward the patient's left) to assess the 4-chamber view.
For the subcostal inferior vena cava (IVC) view, the probe should be slightly rotated
counterclockwise until the IVC can be assessed.
Standard Medical Care Step 3: Management strategies Step 3 in the EGHEM/EGAM process is to
define patient management strategies based on the pre-op TTE assessment. The main goals of
patient management are to maintain normal cardiac output and filling pressure. Primary and
secondary findings and the associated EGAM strategies to achieve these goals are outlined in
Table 1 and Table 2, respectively.
Table 1: Primary findings and associated management strategy to maintain normal cardiac
output and filling pressure.
Echo-Generated Findings EGHEM/EGAM Strategy Cardiac output status Filling pressure status
Normal High Preload reduction Low Normal Afterload reduction Low High Afterload and preload
reduction High High Preload reduction High Normal or low Increase preload
Table 2: Secondary findings and associated management strategy to optimize patient
management.
Echo-Generated Finding EGHEM/EGAM Strategy Filling Pressure Other High Aortic stenosis
Preload reduction Normal Aortic stenosis Safe for afterload reduction
- Mitral regurgitation Afterload reduction
- Low contractility Inotropic support
- Suspected or confirmed CAD Maintain heart rate in the 50 - 60 bpm range RV volume
overload Preload reduction RV pressure overload Pulmonary afterload reduction Standard
Medical Care Step 4: Ongoing intra-operative assessment Based on the appropriate EGAM
strategy defined in Step 3, either TEE or TTE should be used during the surgical
procedure for the ongoing patient assessment every 15 to 20 minutes. The PI or
Secondary Investigator will determine whether a TEE or TTE should be conducted
intra-operatively. The results of these tests will be used for research purposes.
During surgery: fluid administration, afterload adjustments, and supported
contractility can be implemented to optimize patient management. It is difficult to
assess cardiac output with the current standard medical care without invasive
monitoring. There is minimal risk if the physician gets distracted by the
echocardiogram or the algorithm of the study however it is unlikely this tool would be
a distraction to the physician as it is monitoring the patient.
The randomization is very thought through due to the fact that any
Urology/Gynecology/General surgical patient will be consented for the study so there for no
specific demographics are being recruited other than what is in the inclusion criteria.
Currently for the UNMC Urology/Gynecology surgical patients the distribution lies such that
47 percent are men and 53 percent are women.
Inclusion Criteria:
1. Age ≥ 65 years
2. Hypertension (HTN)
3. Diabetes
4. Obesity (body mass index [BMI] >35)
5. Renal insufficiency
6. Tobacco usage
7. Hypercholesterolemia
8. Sleep apnea/heavy snoring at night
9. Clinical diagnosis of CHF as defined by:
1. Dyspnea on exertion
2. Paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea
3. Orthopnea
4. Elevated jugular venous pressure
5. Pulmonary rales
6. Third heart sound
7. Cardiomegaly or pulmonary edema on chest x-ray
8. Peripheral edema
9. Hepatomegaly
10. Pleural effusion
10. Palpitations/irregular heart beats
11. Chest pain at rest and or exercise
12. Murmur on examination
13. Known coronary artery disease (CAD)/stents/coronary artery bypass graft (CABG)
14. Known valvular disease
15. Known stroke or transient ischemic attacks (TIA)
Exclusion Criteria:
1. Patients expected to say in the hospital for less than 24 hours.
2. Inability of undergo TEE and TTE
3. Clinical evidence or suspicion of elevated intracranial pressure.
4. Preoperative shock or systemic sepsis
5. Emergency Operation
6. ASA Class V
7. Inability of give informed consent
8. Participation in another clinical trial
9. Prisoner
We found this trial at
1
site
Univ of Nebraska Med Ctr A vital enterprise in the nation’s heartland, the University of...
Click here to add this to my saved trials
