The Effects of Caffeine on Force Loss Following Exercise-induced Muscle Damage
Status: | Completed |
---|---|
Conditions: | Healthy Studies |
Therapuetic Areas: | Other |
Healthy: | No |
Age Range: | 18 - 35 |
Updated: | 4/2/2016 |
Start Date: | May 2014 |
End Date: | May 2015 |
Contact: | Christopher Black, PhD |
Email: | cblack@ou.edu |
Phone: | 706-255-3750 |
We have hypothesized: 1) Caffeine will increase maximal voluntary strength compared to
placebo in undamaged muscle. 2) Caffeine will increase muscle activation compared to placebo
in undamaged muscle. 3) Caffeine will enhance spinal excitability (indicated by an enhanced
H-reflex) compared to placebo in undamaged muscle. 4) Caffeine will raise the pressure-pain
threshold (indicating decreased pain sensitivity) in the calf muscle compared to placebo in
undamaged muscle. 5) Caffeine will reduce the amount of low-frequency fatigue, indicated by
an enhanced 20-100 hertz strength ratio, compared to placebo in undamaged muscle. 6)
Caffeine will increase maximal voluntary strength compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 7)
Caffeine will increase muscle activation compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 8) Caffeine
will enhance spinal excitability (indicated by an enhanced H-reflex) compared to placebo in
damaged muscle. 9) Caffeine will raise the pressure-pain threshold (indicating decreased
pain sensitivity) in the calf muscle compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 10) Caffeine
will reduce the amount of low-frequency fatigue, indicated by an enhanced 20-100 hertz
strength ratio, compared to placebo in damaged muscle.
The proposed research will determine the effects of a 5mg/kg body weight dose of caffeine on
muscular strength, activation, H-reflex function, and excitation-contraction coupling before
and after exercise-induced muscle damage. The long term objectives are to gain a better
understanding of caffeine and its affects following exercise-induced muscle damage allowing
us to understand how caffeine is mechanistically interacting with functions of the body.
placebo in undamaged muscle. 2) Caffeine will increase muscle activation compared to placebo
in undamaged muscle. 3) Caffeine will enhance spinal excitability (indicated by an enhanced
H-reflex) compared to placebo in undamaged muscle. 4) Caffeine will raise the pressure-pain
threshold (indicating decreased pain sensitivity) in the calf muscle compared to placebo in
undamaged muscle. 5) Caffeine will reduce the amount of low-frequency fatigue, indicated by
an enhanced 20-100 hertz strength ratio, compared to placebo in undamaged muscle. 6)
Caffeine will increase maximal voluntary strength compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 7)
Caffeine will increase muscle activation compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 8) Caffeine
will enhance spinal excitability (indicated by an enhanced H-reflex) compared to placebo in
damaged muscle. 9) Caffeine will raise the pressure-pain threshold (indicating decreased
pain sensitivity) in the calf muscle compared to placebo in damaged muscle. 10) Caffeine
will reduce the amount of low-frequency fatigue, indicated by an enhanced 20-100 hertz
strength ratio, compared to placebo in damaged muscle.
The proposed research will determine the effects of a 5mg/kg body weight dose of caffeine on
muscular strength, activation, H-reflex function, and excitation-contraction coupling before
and after exercise-induced muscle damage. The long term objectives are to gain a better
understanding of caffeine and its affects following exercise-induced muscle damage allowing
us to understand how caffeine is mechanistically interacting with functions of the body.
A within participant, repeated measures experimental design will be used such that each
participant will serve as his/her own control. Caffeine and placebo will be administered in
a double-blind, counterbalanced manner. Caffeine and placebo (white flour) pills will be
prepared by Kerri Tiedman or Jackie Straughn at the Doctors Park Pharmacy using an
analytical balance. Anhydrous caffeine or white flour will be placed into opaque capsules.
The pills will be placed into envelopes by Chris Black. He will then use a computer
generated random number table to assign caffeine or placebo pills for each testing session
in a counter-balanced fashion. The participant's identification number, as well as session
number will be placed on the envelope. A spreadsheet containing only the participants'
numbers and the testing condition will be kept by Chris Black until the study is complete.
Jessica, Robby, Alex, Josh, and Jamie the research assistants, who will be blinded to the
contents of the envelopes, will administer the pills to the participants and collect data
from the participants. This will ensure the blinding of the researchers to the condition
during data collection. Following the completion of data collection the spreadsheet will be
given to all the above stated research assistants and the blinding will be broken for data
analysis.
Total time commitment for the study will be approximately 10 hours over the course of 14
days. Three familiarization session and 5 testing sessions will be completed.
Test Day 1: - Potential participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab for
a 30 minute session involving the following:
D1.1 Written and verbal description of the experiment and all procedures will be given, and
any questions will be answered. Informed consent will be completed.
D1.2 A physical activity readiness questionnaire (PAR-Q) will be completed (identifies
contraindications to exercise.D1.3 A questionnaire screening for the potential adverse
reactions to caffeine, current medication and supplements as well as an increased risk of
rhabdomyolysis use will be competed. D1.4 Seated, resting blood pressure will be assessed in
the right brachial artery. D1.5 Potential participants deemed eligible for the study will be
asked to orally state to the researchers what they will be expected to do in the study and
explain the risks and benefits of the study to confirm they understand the procedures, time
commitment, freedom to withdraw, and risk and benefits of study participation. D1.6 Next,
participants will practice the procedure for determining maximal voluntary isometric
strength (MVC) of the plantar flexor muscle group. Participants will be seated in a
specially designed chair with their hip at an angle of 90 degrees. A series of 3 maximal,
all-out isometric contractions (contractions against a stationary object where the muscle
does not shorten or lengthen) will be performed. Each contraction will last approximately 3
seconds. Participants will be given verbal encouragement throughout the contraction. Muscle
activation (the amount or percentage of total muscle mass of the plantar flexors the person
is able to use during a contraction) during the isometric contractions will be assessed
using the interpolated-twitch technique (ITT). This technique involves applying an
electrical current to the muscle via stimulation of the tibial motor axon (nerve) while it
is contracting to determine if the muscle is able to generate any additional force, above
and beyond what the participant can generate on their own. The force from this stimulation
is compared to the force generated in a relaxed, non-contracting muscle to determine the
percentage of the muscle the participant can active during a contraction. To perform the ITT
stimulating electrodes are placed proximal to the patella and behind the knee over the
tibial nerve. Participants will receive a brief (10 milliseconds) high intensity stimulation
of the muscle during each contraction, and at 4 and 6 seconds following each contraction
(while the muscle is relaxed). The MVC as well as the ITT will be determined in both the
right and left calf.
Test Day 2: participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 48
hours following testing day 1 for a 15 minute session. D2.1 MVC and muscle activation of the
plantar flexors will be practiced once again as described previously.
Test Day 3: participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 48
hours following testing day 2 for a 15 minute session. D3.1 MVC and muscle activation of the
plantar flexors will be practiced once again as described previously
Testing Day 4: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab for a 2 hour
testing session. D4.1 The pressure pain threshold (PPT) of both the right and left calf
muscles will be assessed. A mark will be placed over the belly of the plantar flexor muscle
group on each leg. Researchers will place a pressure algometer over the test site and will
gradually apply pressure at a rate of 0.50 kg/sec until the participant indicates the
pressure has moved from being "uncomfortable" to "faintly painful." The participant will
indicate this by depressing a button connected to the algometer. As soon as the participant
indicates pain, the pressure stimulus will be removed by the researcher. D4.2 Muscle
soreness in the plantar flexors muscle group will be assessed. This will be done by having
participants perform 3 separate eccentric contractions of the plantar flexors using their
body weight. Participants will be instructed to perform each eccentric contraction in a slow
and controlled manner. After each action the participant will be asked to rate the intensity
of the pain/hurt/soreness in their plantar flexors during the lift. A 10 cm visual analog
scale (VAS) will be used to assess soreness. Participants will be instructed to place a mark
along the 10 cm line that corresponds to the intensity of pain experienced during the lift.
Anchors of "no pain" and "worst pain imaginable" will be placed on the left and right end of
the 10 cm line, respectively. D4.3 Spinal excitability will be assessed by determining the
H-reflex in the tibial nerve. Participants will be seated (as described previously) in the
specially designed chair with their foot secured to a pedal. Two recording electrodes will
be placed on the skin over the belly of the soleus muscle in order to record the electrical
activity (EMG) for the soleus. A ground electrode will be placed over the lateral malleolus.
Stimulating electrodes will be placed over the tibial nerve in the popliteal fossa and
proximal to the patella. A series of 25-30 stimulation pulses will be delivered (each
lasting 1 millisecond) in order to visualize the H and M wave recruitment curve. D4.4
Contractile characteristics of the plantar flexors will be assessed by performing a series
of stimulated contractions (via stimulation of the tibial nerve as described above). Six
stimulated contractions, each lasting 1 second will be performed. Three each at a
stimulation frequency of 20 hertz and 3 at a stimulation frequency of 100 hertz and each
stimulation will be separated by 30 seconds. D4.5 MVC and muscle activation of the plantar
flexors will be assessed as described previously. D4.6 Participants will consume gelatin
capsules containing either a 5mg/kg body weight dose of anhydrous caffeine or a placebo
(white flour). D.4.7 Participants will rest quietly for 60 minutes. D4.8 PPT of the plantar
flexors will be assessed as described previously. D4.9 Muscle soreness will be assessed as
described previously. D4.10 H-reflex will be assessed as described previously D4.11 20 hertz
and 100 hertz contractile characteristics will be assessed as described previously. D4.12
MVC and muscle activation will be assessed as described previously.
Test Day 5: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 24
hours following testing day 4 for a 2 hour testing session. All procedures from test day 4
will be repeated on testing day 5. If participants were randomly assigned to receive
caffeine on testing day 4, they will receive the placebo on day 5, and vice versa.
Test Day 6: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 24
hours following testing day 5 for a 30 minute session.
Participants will complete 60 eccentric muscle actions (6 sets of 10 repetitions) of the
plantar flexors with their dominant leg using a weight approximating 120% of their maximal
strength. Participants will be instructed to perform each eccentric muscle action in a slow
(~ 3 sec) and controlled fashion. Researchers will verbally count during each action to
assist in controlling the speed of the movement. The researchers will raise the weight prior
to the start of each lift. This is so that the participant performs eccentric muscle actions
only. Upon completion of the eccentric exercise, participants will be asked to refrain from
the use of pain relieving medications, including alcohol, until the experiment has been
completed. Participants will also be reminded of the instructions for monitoring symptoms
related to rhabdomyolysis and of the instructions for proper hydration for the duration of
the study.
Test Day 7-8: Participants will report to the applied physiology lab approximately 24 hours
following testing day 6 and 7 for a 2 hour testing session.
All procedures from test day 4 will be repeated during testing day 7 and 8. Caffeine and
placebo capsules will be administered in a counter-balanced fashion such that each
participant will receive caffeine on 1 test day and placebo on the other.
A completely within participants repeated measures ANOVA will be used to test for
differences between each outcome measure between conditions and over time. Assuming a power
of 0.80, a sample size of 20 participants will allow for detection of a difference between
conditions of approximately 0.50 standard deviation (a moderate effect) for the interaction.
Previous studies have demonstrated caffeine enhances strength and the h-reflex by
approximately 0.40-0.90 standard deviation. As such the proposed sample size should be large
enough to detect any meaningful difference between the caffeine and placebo conditions.
The printed hard copies of subject information and data will be kept in a locked file
cabinet in the principle investigator's office which will be locked if he is not there. The
principle investigator will be the only individual with keys to both. All electronic files
for the project will be kept password protected. Only the principle investigator as well as
the respective graduate students will know the password. In the event of an adverse event
the principle investigator. will contact the institutional review board within 2 business
days with the appropriate documentation.
Data and Safety Monitoring Board will be comprised of two members the principle investigator
(Chris Black) and the Co-Investigator (Jessica Renfroe). Monthly meetings will occur between
these members to review data safety practices. If an adverse event were to occur members
will discuss any problems and take action to minimize any further safety concerns within 2
business days.
participant will serve as his/her own control. Caffeine and placebo will be administered in
a double-blind, counterbalanced manner. Caffeine and placebo (white flour) pills will be
prepared by Kerri Tiedman or Jackie Straughn at the Doctors Park Pharmacy using an
analytical balance. Anhydrous caffeine or white flour will be placed into opaque capsules.
The pills will be placed into envelopes by Chris Black. He will then use a computer
generated random number table to assign caffeine or placebo pills for each testing session
in a counter-balanced fashion. The participant's identification number, as well as session
number will be placed on the envelope. A spreadsheet containing only the participants'
numbers and the testing condition will be kept by Chris Black until the study is complete.
Jessica, Robby, Alex, Josh, and Jamie the research assistants, who will be blinded to the
contents of the envelopes, will administer the pills to the participants and collect data
from the participants. This will ensure the blinding of the researchers to the condition
during data collection. Following the completion of data collection the spreadsheet will be
given to all the above stated research assistants and the blinding will be broken for data
analysis.
Total time commitment for the study will be approximately 10 hours over the course of 14
days. Three familiarization session and 5 testing sessions will be completed.
Test Day 1: - Potential participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab for
a 30 minute session involving the following:
D1.1 Written and verbal description of the experiment and all procedures will be given, and
any questions will be answered. Informed consent will be completed.
D1.2 A physical activity readiness questionnaire (PAR-Q) will be completed (identifies
contraindications to exercise.D1.3 A questionnaire screening for the potential adverse
reactions to caffeine, current medication and supplements as well as an increased risk of
rhabdomyolysis use will be competed. D1.4 Seated, resting blood pressure will be assessed in
the right brachial artery. D1.5 Potential participants deemed eligible for the study will be
asked to orally state to the researchers what they will be expected to do in the study and
explain the risks and benefits of the study to confirm they understand the procedures, time
commitment, freedom to withdraw, and risk and benefits of study participation. D1.6 Next,
participants will practice the procedure for determining maximal voluntary isometric
strength (MVC) of the plantar flexor muscle group. Participants will be seated in a
specially designed chair with their hip at an angle of 90 degrees. A series of 3 maximal,
all-out isometric contractions (contractions against a stationary object where the muscle
does not shorten or lengthen) will be performed. Each contraction will last approximately 3
seconds. Participants will be given verbal encouragement throughout the contraction. Muscle
activation (the amount or percentage of total muscle mass of the plantar flexors the person
is able to use during a contraction) during the isometric contractions will be assessed
using the interpolated-twitch technique (ITT). This technique involves applying an
electrical current to the muscle via stimulation of the tibial motor axon (nerve) while it
is contracting to determine if the muscle is able to generate any additional force, above
and beyond what the participant can generate on their own. The force from this stimulation
is compared to the force generated in a relaxed, non-contracting muscle to determine the
percentage of the muscle the participant can active during a contraction. To perform the ITT
stimulating electrodes are placed proximal to the patella and behind the knee over the
tibial nerve. Participants will receive a brief (10 milliseconds) high intensity stimulation
of the muscle during each contraction, and at 4 and 6 seconds following each contraction
(while the muscle is relaxed). The MVC as well as the ITT will be determined in both the
right and left calf.
Test Day 2: participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 48
hours following testing day 1 for a 15 minute session. D2.1 MVC and muscle activation of the
plantar flexors will be practiced once again as described previously.
Test Day 3: participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 48
hours following testing day 2 for a 15 minute session. D3.1 MVC and muscle activation of the
plantar flexors will be practiced once again as described previously
Testing Day 4: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab for a 2 hour
testing session. D4.1 The pressure pain threshold (PPT) of both the right and left calf
muscles will be assessed. A mark will be placed over the belly of the plantar flexor muscle
group on each leg. Researchers will place a pressure algometer over the test site and will
gradually apply pressure at a rate of 0.50 kg/sec until the participant indicates the
pressure has moved from being "uncomfortable" to "faintly painful." The participant will
indicate this by depressing a button connected to the algometer. As soon as the participant
indicates pain, the pressure stimulus will be removed by the researcher. D4.2 Muscle
soreness in the plantar flexors muscle group will be assessed. This will be done by having
participants perform 3 separate eccentric contractions of the plantar flexors using their
body weight. Participants will be instructed to perform each eccentric contraction in a slow
and controlled manner. After each action the participant will be asked to rate the intensity
of the pain/hurt/soreness in their plantar flexors during the lift. A 10 cm visual analog
scale (VAS) will be used to assess soreness. Participants will be instructed to place a mark
along the 10 cm line that corresponds to the intensity of pain experienced during the lift.
Anchors of "no pain" and "worst pain imaginable" will be placed on the left and right end of
the 10 cm line, respectively. D4.3 Spinal excitability will be assessed by determining the
H-reflex in the tibial nerve. Participants will be seated (as described previously) in the
specially designed chair with their foot secured to a pedal. Two recording electrodes will
be placed on the skin over the belly of the soleus muscle in order to record the electrical
activity (EMG) for the soleus. A ground electrode will be placed over the lateral malleolus.
Stimulating electrodes will be placed over the tibial nerve in the popliteal fossa and
proximal to the patella. A series of 25-30 stimulation pulses will be delivered (each
lasting 1 millisecond) in order to visualize the H and M wave recruitment curve. D4.4
Contractile characteristics of the plantar flexors will be assessed by performing a series
of stimulated contractions (via stimulation of the tibial nerve as described above). Six
stimulated contractions, each lasting 1 second will be performed. Three each at a
stimulation frequency of 20 hertz and 3 at a stimulation frequency of 100 hertz and each
stimulation will be separated by 30 seconds. D4.5 MVC and muscle activation of the plantar
flexors will be assessed as described previously. D4.6 Participants will consume gelatin
capsules containing either a 5mg/kg body weight dose of anhydrous caffeine or a placebo
(white flour). D.4.7 Participants will rest quietly for 60 minutes. D4.8 PPT of the plantar
flexors will be assessed as described previously. D4.9 Muscle soreness will be assessed as
described previously. D4.10 H-reflex will be assessed as described previously D4.11 20 hertz
and 100 hertz contractile characteristics will be assessed as described previously. D4.12
MVC and muscle activation will be assessed as described previously.
Test Day 5: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 24
hours following testing day 4 for a 2 hour testing session. All procedures from test day 4
will be repeated on testing day 5. If participants were randomly assigned to receive
caffeine on testing day 4, they will receive the placebo on day 5, and vice versa.
Test Day 6: Participants will report to the sensory and muscle function lab approximately 24
hours following testing day 5 for a 30 minute session.
Participants will complete 60 eccentric muscle actions (6 sets of 10 repetitions) of the
plantar flexors with their dominant leg using a weight approximating 120% of their maximal
strength. Participants will be instructed to perform each eccentric muscle action in a slow
(~ 3 sec) and controlled fashion. Researchers will verbally count during each action to
assist in controlling the speed of the movement. The researchers will raise the weight prior
to the start of each lift. This is so that the participant performs eccentric muscle actions
only. Upon completion of the eccentric exercise, participants will be asked to refrain from
the use of pain relieving medications, including alcohol, until the experiment has been
completed. Participants will also be reminded of the instructions for monitoring symptoms
related to rhabdomyolysis and of the instructions for proper hydration for the duration of
the study.
Test Day 7-8: Participants will report to the applied physiology lab approximately 24 hours
following testing day 6 and 7 for a 2 hour testing session.
All procedures from test day 4 will be repeated during testing day 7 and 8. Caffeine and
placebo capsules will be administered in a counter-balanced fashion such that each
participant will receive caffeine on 1 test day and placebo on the other.
A completely within participants repeated measures ANOVA will be used to test for
differences between each outcome measure between conditions and over time. Assuming a power
of 0.80, a sample size of 20 participants will allow for detection of a difference between
conditions of approximately 0.50 standard deviation (a moderate effect) for the interaction.
Previous studies have demonstrated caffeine enhances strength and the h-reflex by
approximately 0.40-0.90 standard deviation. As such the proposed sample size should be large
enough to detect any meaningful difference between the caffeine and placebo conditions.
The printed hard copies of subject information and data will be kept in a locked file
cabinet in the principle investigator's office which will be locked if he is not there. The
principle investigator will be the only individual with keys to both. All electronic files
for the project will be kept password protected. Only the principle investigator as well as
the respective graduate students will know the password. In the event of an adverse event
the principle investigator. will contact the institutional review board within 2 business
days with the appropriate documentation.
Data and Safety Monitoring Board will be comprised of two members the principle investigator
(Chris Black) and the Co-Investigator (Jessica Renfroe). Monthly meetings will occur between
these members to review data safety practices. If an adverse event were to occur members
will discuss any problems and take action to minimize any further safety concerns within 2
business days.
Inclusion Criteria:
- age range of 18-35 years of age
- males and females who do not have a history of orthopedic injuries of the hip knee,
and/or leg
- Participants must be engaged in some form of physical activity on at least 3 days
each week
Exclusion Criteria:
- An answer of "yes" to any of the seven questions on the physical activity readiness
questionnaire (PAR-Q)
- Average daily consumption of more than 40mg of caffeine per day as determined by the
2 week caffeine recall questionnaire
- Use of any type of prescription psychiatric or prescription or over-the-counter pain
medication
- An answer of "yes" to questions 1,2,8, and 15-22 on the rhabdomyolysis screening
questionnaire
- An answer of "yes" on questions 3,4,6,7,8, 11,12, and 13 if the follow up information
indicates any type of medication, drug, supplement, illness, and/or dietary need that
could affect pain sensitivity or the risk of dehydration. Determinations will be made
on a participant-by-participant basis depending on the answers provided
- An answer of "yes" on question 24 indicating a previous adverse reaction to caffeine
consumption
- Resting systolic blood pressure >140 mmHg and/or resting diastolic blood pressure >90
mmHg
- Pregnancy or suspicion of pregnancy.
We found this trial at
1
site
Click here to add this to my saved trials