Effect of High Protein Weight Loss for Seniors
| Status: | Completed |
|---|---|
| Conditions: | Obesity Weight Loss |
| Therapuetic Areas: | Endocrinology |
| Healthy: | No |
| Age Range: | 65 - 79 |
| Updated: | 1/25/2019 |
| Start Date: | July 1, 2015 |
| End Date: | April 17, 2017 |
Intentional weight loss in obese, older adults remains controversial. Although caloric
restriction, resulting in significant weight and fat mass loss, ameliorates many clinical
consequences of obesity, recommendation of intentional weight loss in aging remains
controversial. Reluctance stems, at least in part, from loss of lean and bone mass known to
accompany overall weight loss and potential exacerbation of age-related risk of disability
and fracture. Accordingly, current treatment guidelines call fhttp://google.wfu.edu/or
weight-loss therapy that minimizes muscle and bone losses for older persons who are obese and
who have functional impairments or medical complications that can benefit from weight loss.
Amount of dietary protein consumed during caloric restriction may be a key determinant in
maintaining fat-free mass during weight loss. Adequate dietary protein is essential for
skeletal muscle anabolism; and, epidemiological evidence in older adults point to a salutary
effect of protein intake above the current RDA (0.8 g/kg/day) on body composition. Indeed, a
recent position statement by the PRO-TAGE study group advises consumption of 1.0-1.2 g/kg/d
in older adults during weight-stable conditions to aid in the maintenance of lean body mass
and function. Practical achievement of this level of protein intake is often difficult for
obese, older adults undergoing weight loss, yet may be critical to offset weight
loss-associated lean mass loss. Preliminary data from our group show a lean mass sparing
effect of high protein consumption during caloric restriction. In post-menopausal women
undergoing a 5-month intentional weight loss program, consumption of a high (1.2 g/kg/day)
versus low (0.6 g/kg/day) protein diet was associated with 50% attenuation (17% vs. 37%) of
lean mass loss. While promising, results have yet to be translated to functional changes in a
tightly controlled trial of weight loss in obese, older adults.
The primary goal of this study is to determine whether adherence to a high protein (≥1.0
g/kg/d) weight loss program results in improved physical function by favorably affecting body
composition compared to weight stability in obese, older adults. This will be accomplished by
conducting a 24-week trial in 124 obese (BMI 30-40 kg/m2), older (65-79 years) men and women,
at risk for mobility disability, randomized to either: (1) high protein intake (≥1.0 g/kg/d;
n=62) during weight loss, or (2) weight-stable control (n=62).
restriction, resulting in significant weight and fat mass loss, ameliorates many clinical
consequences of obesity, recommendation of intentional weight loss in aging remains
controversial. Reluctance stems, at least in part, from loss of lean and bone mass known to
accompany overall weight loss and potential exacerbation of age-related risk of disability
and fracture. Accordingly, current treatment guidelines call fhttp://google.wfu.edu/or
weight-loss therapy that minimizes muscle and bone losses for older persons who are obese and
who have functional impairments or medical complications that can benefit from weight loss.
Amount of dietary protein consumed during caloric restriction may be a key determinant in
maintaining fat-free mass during weight loss. Adequate dietary protein is essential for
skeletal muscle anabolism; and, epidemiological evidence in older adults point to a salutary
effect of protein intake above the current RDA (0.8 g/kg/day) on body composition. Indeed, a
recent position statement by the PRO-TAGE study group advises consumption of 1.0-1.2 g/kg/d
in older adults during weight-stable conditions to aid in the maintenance of lean body mass
and function. Practical achievement of this level of protein intake is often difficult for
obese, older adults undergoing weight loss, yet may be critical to offset weight
loss-associated lean mass loss. Preliminary data from our group show a lean mass sparing
effect of high protein consumption during caloric restriction. In post-menopausal women
undergoing a 5-month intentional weight loss program, consumption of a high (1.2 g/kg/day)
versus low (0.6 g/kg/day) protein diet was associated with 50% attenuation (17% vs. 37%) of
lean mass loss. While promising, results have yet to be translated to functional changes in a
tightly controlled trial of weight loss in obese, older adults.
The primary goal of this study is to determine whether adherence to a high protein (≥1.0
g/kg/d) weight loss program results in improved physical function by favorably affecting body
composition compared to weight stability in obese, older adults. This will be accomplished by
conducting a 24-week trial in 124 obese (BMI 30-40 kg/m2), older (65-79 years) men and women,
at risk for mobility disability, randomized to either: (1) high protein intake (≥1.0 g/kg/d;
n=62) during weight loss, or (2) weight-stable control (n=62).
Aging and obesity are prevalent risk factors for morbidity and mortality. By 2030, Americans
aged 65 and older will number an estimated 72 million people,1 half of whom will be obese.
Both advanced age and obesity are well-characterized risk factors for chronic disease and
disability suggesting that the individual and societal health burden of age- and
obesity-related conditions will increase substantially.
Emerging results from randomized controlled trials demonstrate caloric restriction and
exercise interventions, resulting in weight loss of 7-10%, are associated with initial
improvement in muscle strength and function in older adults; however, in few cases has the
effect of caloric restriction, independent of exercise, been evaluated and no randomized
controlled trials have examined the role of specific dietary components, as adjuvants to
weight loss, on physical function. Evidence supporting a diet-based weight loss approach in
obese, older adults with functional impairments has tremendous clinical significance as
multiple behavior changes are often difficult to implement and maintain, and many older
adults are unable (or unwilling) to engage in the amount of physical activity typically
prescribed in lifestyle-based interventions.
In exploratory analyses we will also examine the effects of intentional weight loss on a
compilation of physiologic and biochemical markers (including: respiratory and kidney
function, cognitive processing speed, inflammation, and blood pressure), shown in
epidemiologic investigations to predict mortality. Meta-analytic data from our group suggest
a 15% reduction in mortality for obese adults undergoing intentional weight loss and better
understanding of the potential mechanism(s) underlying this association is of great clinical
interest.
Methods and Measures
Recruitment: We plan to recruit up to 124 obese (BMI=30-40 kg/m2), older (age=65-79 years)
men and women with mobility disability from communities in and around Forsyth County, NC via
media advertisements, mass mailings, and direct mailings.
Participant screening, assessments and randomization
All participants will initially be screened via telephone to determine general eligibility.
Individuals who pass the telephone screening will be scheduled for a visit at the Sticht
Center on Aging for a screening visit. Before any data collection, all participants will be
asked to provide written informed consent to participate in the study and complete a HIPAA
authorization form in accordance with the WFSM Institutional Review Board policies.
At the screening visit, all inclusion and exclusion criteria will be reviewed (including
participant demographics and measurement of weight and height to calculate BMI). After
confirmation of meeting demographic and BMI criteria (this may be the same day as the
screening visit), participants will proceed with Baseline Visit 1 (BV1) assessments,
including a fasting blood draw for a metabolic panel, blood cell count, and blood for
storage. After a snack, participants will undergo further assessment for blood pressure,
depression (using the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; CES-D), cognition
(using the Montreal Cognitive Assessment; MoCA), processing speed (Digit Symbol Substitution
test; DSST), spirometry (FEV1), waist circumference, and grip and leg power/strength. At the
end of this visit, participants will be provided with instruction on how to collect
accelerometry data and a 24-hour urinary specimen to assess protein intake, both of which
will be collected at the subsequent testing session. Because several measures that are taken
at the BV1 visit also serve as screening tests (including: blood work from the metabolic
panel, blood pressure, depression, and cognition), any person with results from these tests
that do not meet eligibility criteria will not be invited to enroll and as indicated, advised
to share any abnormal test results with their physician. Also, any participant with abnormal
test results at the follow-up testing visits will be referred for further medical evaluation.
The second baseline testing session (BV2) will occur in the Wake Forest University Department
of Health and Exercise Science. During this visit, participants will undergo muscle function
tests (expanded Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) test, Timed-Up-and-Go (TUG) test,
fast 20-meter and 400-meter walk tests, and stair climb test), DXA scan (whole body, hip and
spine), physical activity questionnaire (Community Healthy Activities Model Program for
Seniors; CHAMPS), quality of life questionnaire (SF-12), disability questionnaires (Pepper
Assessment Tool for Disability; PAT-D and Mobility Assessment Tool-short form; MAT-sf), and
instructions will be provided for a dietary run-in (approximately 30 minutes). For the
dietary run-in, all participants will be provided with and oriented to the Medifast®
QuickStart Guide, sample meal plans, 3, one-day dietary trackers, a sampling of 12 Medifast
Meal Replacement Products, 3, one-day Product Evaluation Forms, and asked to follow the
Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 PlanTM for a three day period occurring over the following week.
Participants will be contacted by the study registered dietitian (RD) upon completion of the
dietary run in period to assess their willingness and self-efficacy to adhere to the dietary
protocol for the duration of the study (24 weeks). Participants who indicate that they are
willing and able to follow the protocol will be randomized (RAND) to one of the 2 study
interventions (high protein weight loss group vs. weight stable control group), with blocking
stratified by gender, and treated in 5 successive waves (n=12-13 participants/group/wave).
Randomization of the entire wave (n=24-26) will occur approximately 1week prior to the start
of intervention, and at this time the first monthly Medifast product order will be placed for
participants randomized to the high protein weight loss group.
All assessments conducted at the BV1 and BV2 testing sessions will be repeated at two
follow-up visits (FV1 and FV2), occurring during the last two weeks of active intervention
(weeks 23-24). Lastly, a brief midpoint visit (MP; week 12) will occur for all participants,
where only DXA and fast 400-meter walk tests will be performed.
Study Interventions
The high protein weight loss group will follow the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan™, targeting ~10%
weight loss over the 24-week study. Weight loss will be monitored bi-weekly to ensure the
safety of the study participants. This level of weight loss will be achieved through a
combination of meal replacement products (MRPs), meal plans, and individual
nutrition/behavioral counseling.
All participants will also attend behavioral counseling group classes led by the RD and held
bi-weekly for the duration of the study. An additional phone call at week 1 will be made to
provide participants an opportunity to review specific questions and problems. Weight will be
measured bi-weekly, at each class, to provide additional feedback and to increase motivation.
Additionally, participants will complete daily food logs which will be reviewed by the RD to
verify compliance to the diet.
The weight stable control group will be monitored bi-weekly by study staff (with an
additional phone call at week 1) to ensure weight stability over the course of the study.
Participants will be weighed on a bi-weekly basis and encouraged to maintain weight within
±5% of baseline. To promote compliance and retention, participants will also be invited to
bi-weekly group educational sessions, where non-weight loss health related topics will be
presented by study staff. Lastly, if weight stable participants are able to attend 75% (i.e.
9 of 12) educational sessions, all baseline and follow-up testing sessions, and maintain
weight stability over the course of the study (defined as less than a 5% differential between
weight measured at week 0 and 24), they will be eligible to receive up to 3 months of
Medifast MRPs along with a 30-60 minute RD-led dietary instruction session on how to follow
the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan.
Study Measure(s)
Height, body mass, BMI, & waist circumference. Height without shoes will be measured to the
nearest 0.1 centimeter using a stadiometer and body mass will be measured to the nearest 0.1
kilogram using a calibrated and certified balance beam scale. Height and body mass will be
used to calculate BMI. Waist circumference will be measured to the nearest 0.1 cm with a
Gulick-II spring-retractable steel tape.
Muscle function and strength measures will be conducted before and after the interventions,
with the exception of the 400-meter walk test, which will also be performed at the study
midpoint (12-weeks). Gait speed will be assessed using the fast 20-meter and 400-meter walk
tests. The 400-meter walk tests was originally developed in Health ABC and used by our group
in the CLIP and LIFE studies. Participants are asked to walk 10 laps of a 40-meter course (20
meters out and 20 meters back) per standardized instructional script. The reliability and
validity of the 400-meter walk test are excellent and performance is an important prognostic
indicator for total mortality, cardiovascular disease, and mobility disability in older
adults. Physical performance will be assessed using the expanded Short Physical Performance
Battery (SPPB). The expanded SPPB consists of 5 repeated chair stands, standing balance
(semi- and full-tandem stands and a single leg stand for 30 seconds), a 4-meter walk to
assess usual gait speed, and a narrow 4-meter walk test of balance (walking at usual pace
within lines of tape spaced 20 cm apart).Scores for the traditional 0-12 point SPPB can also
be obtained from these tests. Physical performance will also be assessed using the
Timed-Up-and-Go (TUG). TUG measures the time a person takes to stand up from a standard
chair, walk 3 meters, turn, walk back to the chair, and sit down again. A practice trial is
given, followed by two timed trials and the results of the timed trials are averaged. Stair
climbing time will be assessed by measuring the fastest time achieved to climb 4 steps on a
4-step staircase (test will be performed 2 times). Lower extremity muscle power will be
measured using the Nottingham Power Rig, a safe, convenient method for assessing power output
from the lower limb which has been used reliably in older adults. Participants will sit in a
chair and unilaterally depress a foot lever attached to a flywheel as hard and as fast as
they can. Power output, derived from the acceleration of the flywheel, will be recorded in
Watts. Power will be averaged for each leg following 5 trials at maximal effort. Participants
that have had a unilateral hip or knee replacement should not have that side tested.
Participants who have had eye surgery (e.g., cataract surgery) within the past month should
not be tested. Lower extremity muscle strength will be measured using an isokinetic
dynamometer (Biodex/KinCom) at one speed (60°/sec) with the participant sitting and the hips
and knee flexed at 90°. The dynamometer will be adjusted for each participant and all
adjustments will be recorded to duplicate the position for subsequent assessments. Start and
stop angles will be set at 90° and 30°. Participants will be asked to extend the knee and
push as hard as possible against the resistance pad. Strength is expressed as peak torque in
Newton-meters (Nm). The best performance of 3 trials will be selected for each side, and the
averages of the left and right leg will be used in analyses. Grip strength will be measured
twice in each hand to the nearest 2 kg using an isometric Hydraulic Hand Dynamometer (Jamar,
Bolingbrook, IL) and the mean value from the stronger hand used. Participants will be
excluded from performing the test if they report hand-pain or recent hand or wrist surgery.
Body composition. Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (iDXA, GE Medical Systems, Madison, WI;
located in the Health and Exercise Science Department, WFU). Whole body scans will be
acquired with the participant supine and aligned with the scanner table as prescribed by the
manufacturer. DXA will also be used to analyze bone mineral density (BMD) using specific
scans of the anterior-posterior (AP) spine (L1-L4) and proximal femur. Coefficients of
variation (CV) from repeated measurements are 1.0% for lumbar spine BMD and 1.0% for femur
BMD. All scans will be performed and analyzed by our trained DXA technician who is certified
by the International Society for Clinical Densitometry and has vast experience in body
composition measurements in older adults. Every scan will be examined to evaluate for proper
patient positioning and analysis, and reanalysis or rescanning will be performed if
necessary. Any artifacts will be noted and, if possible, excluded from the measured region.
Daily quality control scans are obtained with GE's phantoms.
Accelerometry will be used to objectively assess physical activity over a 7-day period at
baseline and at follow-up by a compact, hip mounted electronic pedometer, using a 3-axis
accelerometer and digital filtering algorithms to measure the amount and frequency of
movement over 24 hours for up to 40 days.
Cognitive function will be assessed during screening using the Montreal Cognitive Assessment
(MoCA), participants must score >18 to be eligible. We will also assess psychomotor speed,
attention, and working memory using the Digit Symbol Substitution Test (DSST). Participants
are given a series of numbered symbols and then asked to draw the appropriate symbols below a
list of random numbers. The score is the number of correctly made matches in 2 minutes (120
seconds). The cognitive function tests will be audio recorded by the assessor using a hand
held digital recorder. The recordings will be used to properly score the tests as well as be
available for quality control testing. The recordings will be deleted once the study is over
and the data that was entered has been verified.
Ventilatory capacity will be assessed by spirometry recorded by the EasyOne™ PLUS spirometer
to record average FEV1 over three reproducible trials. Kidney function will be assessed by
obtaining a basic metabolic panel (BMP) at baseline and follow up. Blood pressure and pulse
will be measured in the right arm, using an automatic Omron device, with the participant in a
seated position after having rested quietly for 5 minutes. Subjects will sit with feet flat
on the floor and legs uncrossed and will be asked not to talk during the rest period or
during the measurement. Appropriate cuff size will be used. Systolic and diastolic blood
pressure will be defined as the average of two repeated measures. Interleukin-6 will be
assessed in plasma samples that will be measured in blood drawn after an overnight fast at
baseline and follow up. Finally, serum and plasma will be collected and stored for later
assessment of biomarkers to identify potential mechanisms underlying the effects of the
intervention on muscle and bone loss during weight loss.
Demographic characteristics including age, gender, race, education level, and socio-economic
status will be recorded and used as covariates if necessary. Physical activity will be
measured using the CHAMPS Physical Activity Questionnaire for Older Adults at baseline and
follow-up.32 Activities of daily living will be assessed using the Pepper Assessment Tool for
Disability (PAT-D) at baseline and follow-up. Additionally, activities of daily living will
be assessed using the Mobility Assessment Tool - Short Form (MAT-sf) at baseline and
follow-up. This is a novel, computerized tool for self-assessment of functional performance
designed to reduce bias from factors such as age, gender and body image. The Short Form 12
(SF-12) will be used as a generic measure of health related quality of life. The
questionnaire consists of two norm-based composite T-scales, assessing mental health and
physical function. Lastly, mood will be assessed using the 10-item Center for Epidemiologic
Studies Depression Scale (CES-D).
Compliance and satisfaction will be controlled by the use of behavioral strategies including
weight status collection at regular, bi-weekly intervals for both groups. Additionally,
participants randomized to the high protein weight loss group will be asked to provide
information on daily dietary intake and complete a satisfaction survey at the end of
intervention to express thoughts and feelings about following the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan.
Lastly, 24-hour urine nitrogen will be assessed to ensure differential protein intake by
sending participants home with a container and instructions at baseline and follow up.
Participants will be asked to: (1) void at 8 AM and discard the specimen; (2) collect all
urine including the final specimen voided at the end of the 24-hour collection period (i.e.,
8 AM the next morning); (3) screw the lid on securely. The sample can be stored at room
temperature or refrigerated for up to 14 days and when the sample is returned, it will be
sent to Labcorp for analysis.
Unpublished data collected in older participants undergoing a 6-month weight loss
intervention indicate that it i possible to generate a clinically meaningful 400-meter walk
gait speed difference of at least 0.05 m/s, with a common group standard deviation of 0.19
m/s and a correlation of 0.85 between baseline and 6-month measures. An analysis of
covariance (ANCOVA) analytic approach will be used to fit the randomization effect and
baseline gait speed, then 53 subjects completing the intervention per group will yield 80%
power using a two-sided alternative hypothesis at the 0.05 level of significance. Assuming a
conservative drop-out rate of 15%, there is a 124 participants (n=62/group) enrollment goal.
To facilitate data transfer and preserve records that can be audited, hard copy forms will be
collected. All data will be manually entered within one week of collection into the study
database. The data entry system will protect confidentiality and data security and the use of
text containing identifying information will be avoided. Data will reside on a server in a
Microsoft SQL server database with daily backup.
Regression diagnostics, residual plots, and exploratory analyses will be performed to find
appropriate transformations for all variables to satisfy linearity, homogeneity of variances,
and normality assumptions. Descriptive statistics consisting of frequency tables and
percentages for categorical variables, and means, standard deviations, medians, and ranges
for continuous variables will be tabulated and presented by intervention group and time
point. Exact 95% confidence intervals (CIs) will be provided for the estimated proportions
and approximate 95% CIs for estimated means. The primary outcome of the intervention effect
on fast 400-meter walk gait speed will be analyzed using an ANCOVA model fit with the main
effect of treatment arm and adjusted for baseline values of fast 400-meter walk gait speed.
The primary test will be covariate-adjusted main treatment effect of the weight loss
intervention compared to the control group, and we assume a Type I error rate of 0.05 for the
two-sided alternative hypothesis. Secondary measures of body composition will be analyzed
similarly, using baseline values of the particular body composition measure as a covariate in
the outcome model. Other data including feasibility and compliance data collected in this
study will be used to inform future studies of weight loss in older adults. All statistical
analyses will be conducted assuming intent-to-treat so that participants will remain assigned
to the initial randomization group regardless of treatment adherence, and participants who do
not adhere or discontinue treatment will still be encouraged to provide outcomes data. Our
group has past success in retaining participants by maintaining frequent contact with
individuals who encounter barriers to participation and creatively accommodate and counsel,
as necessary, to encourage the maximum degree of participation. To ensure the results are not
overly influenced by missing data, a multiple imputation sensitivity analysis of the primary
outcome will be performed using both baseline and post-randomization characteristics to
inform the missing data imputation, assuming observations are missing at random.
Human Subjects Protection
Subjects will be recruited using community-based recruitment strategies including mass and
direct mailings and the local newspapers. We will also advertise in the VITAL newsletter
(BG99-559) and participate in community outreach events.
Informed Consent
Written informed consent will be obtained from each subject and consistent with the
procedures of the WFU Institutional Review Board. The study interviewers will explain the
purpose, methods and extent of the study to prospective participants. The potential
participant is asked to read the informed consent form and ask questions. The form is written
in simple easy to understand language. We require study staff to review all of the key
aspects of the study verbally with the potential participants. Staff is provided with a
structured checklist for this purpose. Staff is then required to question potential
participants to ascertain whether s/he has understood the information. Potential participants
who are illiterate or have impaired vision must have the consent read to them, followed by
review of the checklist, opportunity for questions, and discussion. This process will take
place in a quiet, private room in the Sticht Center. A copy of the signed and dated consent
form will be given to participants, and the original document will be placed in subjects'
individual study files, which will be stored in a secure location. In compliance with the
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Standards for Privacy of
Individually Identifiable Health Information of the Department of Health and Human Services,
we will access personal health information only after obtaining informed consent.
Potential Risks
1. Blood draw. Slight discomfort, bruising, and/or infection at the sight of puncture for
blood drawing, but blood will be drawn only by trained and experienced phlebotomists who
will minimize the discomfort as much as possible.
2. Physical Performance Testing. There is a risk of the participant losing their balance
and falling associated with the physical performance-based testing (e.g., the fast
400-meter walk test, balance tests, rising from a chair, muscle strength and power
testing). In rare instances persons doing the fast 400-meter walk test will experience
leg or chest pain, heart palpitations, shortness of breath. In very rare situations
exercise can result in heart attack or sudden death. We will minimize this risk by: (1)
safely escorting participants to chairs located along the walking course should they
become unsteady; (2) following them at a close distance; and, (3) being at their side
should they need assistance. There is a risk that participants may experience muscle
soreness, strains, pulls, falls or joint injury or discomfort as a result of the
physical performance testing procedures. A warm-up and range of motion practice will be
conducted before maximal strength testing. In addition, if a participant reports pain,
dizziness, lightheadedness or other medical problem during the test, the test will be
terminated.
3. DXA scans. Exposure to radiation from the whole body, anterior-posterior (AP) spine
(L1-L4), and proximal femur DXA (45 mRem total) for baseline, mid-point, and follow-up
scans.
Confidentiality and Privacy
Confidentiality will be protected by collecting only information needed to assess study
outcomes, minimizing to the fullest extent possible the collection of any information that
could directly identify subjects, and maintaining all study information in a secure manner.
To help ensure subject privacy and confidentiality, only a unique study identifier will
appear on the data collection form. Any collected patient identifying information
corresponding to the unique study identifier will be maintained on a separate master log. The
master log will be kept secure, with access limited to designated study personnel. Following
data collection, subject identifying information will be destroyed at the earliest
opportunity (following a minimum of 3 years of record retention per the Wake Forest School of
Medicine IRB policy), consistent with data validation and study design, producing an
anonymous analytical data set. Data access will be limited to study staff, and also to
Medifast Clinical Affairs personnel. Data and records will be kept locked and secured, with
any computer data password protected. No reference to any individual participant will appear
in reports, presentations, or publications that may arise from the study.
Data and Safety Monitoring
The principal investigator will be responsible for the overall monitoring of the data and
safety of study participants. The principal investigator will be assisted by other members of
the study staff, including the study physician, Rebecca Henderson, MD. In addition, all
project related data and safety will be reviewed biannually by the WFUSM's Older Americans
Independence Center's (OAIC) independent Data Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB).
Reporting of Unanticipated Problems, Adverse Events or Deviations Participants will be
queried at bi-weekly intervention sessions for adverse events (AE). Events will be recorded
on AE tracking forms and categorized based on severity (mild/moderate/severe), seriousness
(yes/no), and relatedness to the study intervention (unrelated, possibly, probably, and
definitely). Any unanticipated problems, including serious and unexpected adverse events, as
well as deviations or protocol changes will be promptly reported by the principal
investigator or project manager to the IRB, the WFUSM OAIC DSMB, and Medifast.
Use of biological samples by other investigators
Biological samples may be used by investigators other than the investigators of the current
study under the terms outlined in the informed consent form. The use will be limited to
non-commercial purposes. The names and other personal identifiers of the study participants
will not be sent to any recipients of the blood samples.
Storage and disposal of biological material
Biologic samples will be stored at Wake Forest University Medical Center for up to twenty
years after the end of the trial at which time the samples will be destroyed. All the
specimens will have numerical study IDs with no personal identifiers of the participants.
These are stored under the Pepper Center Repository (IRB#1219).
aged 65 and older will number an estimated 72 million people,1 half of whom will be obese.
Both advanced age and obesity are well-characterized risk factors for chronic disease and
disability suggesting that the individual and societal health burden of age- and
obesity-related conditions will increase substantially.
Emerging results from randomized controlled trials demonstrate caloric restriction and
exercise interventions, resulting in weight loss of 7-10%, are associated with initial
improvement in muscle strength and function in older adults; however, in few cases has the
effect of caloric restriction, independent of exercise, been evaluated and no randomized
controlled trials have examined the role of specific dietary components, as adjuvants to
weight loss, on physical function. Evidence supporting a diet-based weight loss approach in
obese, older adults with functional impairments has tremendous clinical significance as
multiple behavior changes are often difficult to implement and maintain, and many older
adults are unable (or unwilling) to engage in the amount of physical activity typically
prescribed in lifestyle-based interventions.
In exploratory analyses we will also examine the effects of intentional weight loss on a
compilation of physiologic and biochemical markers (including: respiratory and kidney
function, cognitive processing speed, inflammation, and blood pressure), shown in
epidemiologic investigations to predict mortality. Meta-analytic data from our group suggest
a 15% reduction in mortality for obese adults undergoing intentional weight loss and better
understanding of the potential mechanism(s) underlying this association is of great clinical
interest.
Methods and Measures
Recruitment: We plan to recruit up to 124 obese (BMI=30-40 kg/m2), older (age=65-79 years)
men and women with mobility disability from communities in and around Forsyth County, NC via
media advertisements, mass mailings, and direct mailings.
Participant screening, assessments and randomization
All participants will initially be screened via telephone to determine general eligibility.
Individuals who pass the telephone screening will be scheduled for a visit at the Sticht
Center on Aging for a screening visit. Before any data collection, all participants will be
asked to provide written informed consent to participate in the study and complete a HIPAA
authorization form in accordance with the WFSM Institutional Review Board policies.
At the screening visit, all inclusion and exclusion criteria will be reviewed (including
participant demographics and measurement of weight and height to calculate BMI). After
confirmation of meeting demographic and BMI criteria (this may be the same day as the
screening visit), participants will proceed with Baseline Visit 1 (BV1) assessments,
including a fasting blood draw for a metabolic panel, blood cell count, and blood for
storage. After a snack, participants will undergo further assessment for blood pressure,
depression (using the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; CES-D), cognition
(using the Montreal Cognitive Assessment; MoCA), processing speed (Digit Symbol Substitution
test; DSST), spirometry (FEV1), waist circumference, and grip and leg power/strength. At the
end of this visit, participants will be provided with instruction on how to collect
accelerometry data and a 24-hour urinary specimen to assess protein intake, both of which
will be collected at the subsequent testing session. Because several measures that are taken
at the BV1 visit also serve as screening tests (including: blood work from the metabolic
panel, blood pressure, depression, and cognition), any person with results from these tests
that do not meet eligibility criteria will not be invited to enroll and as indicated, advised
to share any abnormal test results with their physician. Also, any participant with abnormal
test results at the follow-up testing visits will be referred for further medical evaluation.
The second baseline testing session (BV2) will occur in the Wake Forest University Department
of Health and Exercise Science. During this visit, participants will undergo muscle function
tests (expanded Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) test, Timed-Up-and-Go (TUG) test,
fast 20-meter and 400-meter walk tests, and stair climb test), DXA scan (whole body, hip and
spine), physical activity questionnaire (Community Healthy Activities Model Program for
Seniors; CHAMPS), quality of life questionnaire (SF-12), disability questionnaires (Pepper
Assessment Tool for Disability; PAT-D and Mobility Assessment Tool-short form; MAT-sf), and
instructions will be provided for a dietary run-in (approximately 30 minutes). For the
dietary run-in, all participants will be provided with and oriented to the Medifast®
QuickStart Guide, sample meal plans, 3, one-day dietary trackers, a sampling of 12 Medifast
Meal Replacement Products, 3, one-day Product Evaluation Forms, and asked to follow the
Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 PlanTM for a three day period occurring over the following week.
Participants will be contacted by the study registered dietitian (RD) upon completion of the
dietary run in period to assess their willingness and self-efficacy to adhere to the dietary
protocol for the duration of the study (24 weeks). Participants who indicate that they are
willing and able to follow the protocol will be randomized (RAND) to one of the 2 study
interventions (high protein weight loss group vs. weight stable control group), with blocking
stratified by gender, and treated in 5 successive waves (n=12-13 participants/group/wave).
Randomization of the entire wave (n=24-26) will occur approximately 1week prior to the start
of intervention, and at this time the first monthly Medifast product order will be placed for
participants randomized to the high protein weight loss group.
All assessments conducted at the BV1 and BV2 testing sessions will be repeated at two
follow-up visits (FV1 and FV2), occurring during the last two weeks of active intervention
(weeks 23-24). Lastly, a brief midpoint visit (MP; week 12) will occur for all participants,
where only DXA and fast 400-meter walk tests will be performed.
Study Interventions
The high protein weight loss group will follow the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan™, targeting ~10%
weight loss over the 24-week study. Weight loss will be monitored bi-weekly to ensure the
safety of the study participants. This level of weight loss will be achieved through a
combination of meal replacement products (MRPs), meal plans, and individual
nutrition/behavioral counseling.
All participants will also attend behavioral counseling group classes led by the RD and held
bi-weekly for the duration of the study. An additional phone call at week 1 will be made to
provide participants an opportunity to review specific questions and problems. Weight will be
measured bi-weekly, at each class, to provide additional feedback and to increase motivation.
Additionally, participants will complete daily food logs which will be reviewed by the RD to
verify compliance to the diet.
The weight stable control group will be monitored bi-weekly by study staff (with an
additional phone call at week 1) to ensure weight stability over the course of the study.
Participants will be weighed on a bi-weekly basis and encouraged to maintain weight within
±5% of baseline. To promote compliance and retention, participants will also be invited to
bi-weekly group educational sessions, where non-weight loss health related topics will be
presented by study staff. Lastly, if weight stable participants are able to attend 75% (i.e.
9 of 12) educational sessions, all baseline and follow-up testing sessions, and maintain
weight stability over the course of the study (defined as less than a 5% differential between
weight measured at week 0 and 24), they will be eligible to receive up to 3 months of
Medifast MRPs along with a 30-60 minute RD-led dietary instruction session on how to follow
the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan.
Study Measure(s)
Height, body mass, BMI, & waist circumference. Height without shoes will be measured to the
nearest 0.1 centimeter using a stadiometer and body mass will be measured to the nearest 0.1
kilogram using a calibrated and certified balance beam scale. Height and body mass will be
used to calculate BMI. Waist circumference will be measured to the nearest 0.1 cm with a
Gulick-II spring-retractable steel tape.
Muscle function and strength measures will be conducted before and after the interventions,
with the exception of the 400-meter walk test, which will also be performed at the study
midpoint (12-weeks). Gait speed will be assessed using the fast 20-meter and 400-meter walk
tests. The 400-meter walk tests was originally developed in Health ABC and used by our group
in the CLIP and LIFE studies. Participants are asked to walk 10 laps of a 40-meter course (20
meters out and 20 meters back) per standardized instructional script. The reliability and
validity of the 400-meter walk test are excellent and performance is an important prognostic
indicator for total mortality, cardiovascular disease, and mobility disability in older
adults. Physical performance will be assessed using the expanded Short Physical Performance
Battery (SPPB). The expanded SPPB consists of 5 repeated chair stands, standing balance
(semi- and full-tandem stands and a single leg stand for 30 seconds), a 4-meter walk to
assess usual gait speed, and a narrow 4-meter walk test of balance (walking at usual pace
within lines of tape spaced 20 cm apart).Scores for the traditional 0-12 point SPPB can also
be obtained from these tests. Physical performance will also be assessed using the
Timed-Up-and-Go (TUG). TUG measures the time a person takes to stand up from a standard
chair, walk 3 meters, turn, walk back to the chair, and sit down again. A practice trial is
given, followed by two timed trials and the results of the timed trials are averaged. Stair
climbing time will be assessed by measuring the fastest time achieved to climb 4 steps on a
4-step staircase (test will be performed 2 times). Lower extremity muscle power will be
measured using the Nottingham Power Rig, a safe, convenient method for assessing power output
from the lower limb which has been used reliably in older adults. Participants will sit in a
chair and unilaterally depress a foot lever attached to a flywheel as hard and as fast as
they can. Power output, derived from the acceleration of the flywheel, will be recorded in
Watts. Power will be averaged for each leg following 5 trials at maximal effort. Participants
that have had a unilateral hip or knee replacement should not have that side tested.
Participants who have had eye surgery (e.g., cataract surgery) within the past month should
not be tested. Lower extremity muscle strength will be measured using an isokinetic
dynamometer (Biodex/KinCom) at one speed (60°/sec) with the participant sitting and the hips
and knee flexed at 90°. The dynamometer will be adjusted for each participant and all
adjustments will be recorded to duplicate the position for subsequent assessments. Start and
stop angles will be set at 90° and 30°. Participants will be asked to extend the knee and
push as hard as possible against the resistance pad. Strength is expressed as peak torque in
Newton-meters (Nm). The best performance of 3 trials will be selected for each side, and the
averages of the left and right leg will be used in analyses. Grip strength will be measured
twice in each hand to the nearest 2 kg using an isometric Hydraulic Hand Dynamometer (Jamar,
Bolingbrook, IL) and the mean value from the stronger hand used. Participants will be
excluded from performing the test if they report hand-pain or recent hand or wrist surgery.
Body composition. Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (iDXA, GE Medical Systems, Madison, WI;
located in the Health and Exercise Science Department, WFU). Whole body scans will be
acquired with the participant supine and aligned with the scanner table as prescribed by the
manufacturer. DXA will also be used to analyze bone mineral density (BMD) using specific
scans of the anterior-posterior (AP) spine (L1-L4) and proximal femur. Coefficients of
variation (CV) from repeated measurements are 1.0% for lumbar spine BMD and 1.0% for femur
BMD. All scans will be performed and analyzed by our trained DXA technician who is certified
by the International Society for Clinical Densitometry and has vast experience in body
composition measurements in older adults. Every scan will be examined to evaluate for proper
patient positioning and analysis, and reanalysis or rescanning will be performed if
necessary. Any artifacts will be noted and, if possible, excluded from the measured region.
Daily quality control scans are obtained with GE's phantoms.
Accelerometry will be used to objectively assess physical activity over a 7-day period at
baseline and at follow-up by a compact, hip mounted electronic pedometer, using a 3-axis
accelerometer and digital filtering algorithms to measure the amount and frequency of
movement over 24 hours for up to 40 days.
Cognitive function will be assessed during screening using the Montreal Cognitive Assessment
(MoCA), participants must score >18 to be eligible. We will also assess psychomotor speed,
attention, and working memory using the Digit Symbol Substitution Test (DSST). Participants
are given a series of numbered symbols and then asked to draw the appropriate symbols below a
list of random numbers. The score is the number of correctly made matches in 2 minutes (120
seconds). The cognitive function tests will be audio recorded by the assessor using a hand
held digital recorder. The recordings will be used to properly score the tests as well as be
available for quality control testing. The recordings will be deleted once the study is over
and the data that was entered has been verified.
Ventilatory capacity will be assessed by spirometry recorded by the EasyOne™ PLUS spirometer
to record average FEV1 over three reproducible trials. Kidney function will be assessed by
obtaining a basic metabolic panel (BMP) at baseline and follow up. Blood pressure and pulse
will be measured in the right arm, using an automatic Omron device, with the participant in a
seated position after having rested quietly for 5 minutes. Subjects will sit with feet flat
on the floor and legs uncrossed and will be asked not to talk during the rest period or
during the measurement. Appropriate cuff size will be used. Systolic and diastolic blood
pressure will be defined as the average of two repeated measures. Interleukin-6 will be
assessed in plasma samples that will be measured in blood drawn after an overnight fast at
baseline and follow up. Finally, serum and plasma will be collected and stored for later
assessment of biomarkers to identify potential mechanisms underlying the effects of the
intervention on muscle and bone loss during weight loss.
Demographic characteristics including age, gender, race, education level, and socio-economic
status will be recorded and used as covariates if necessary. Physical activity will be
measured using the CHAMPS Physical Activity Questionnaire for Older Adults at baseline and
follow-up.32 Activities of daily living will be assessed using the Pepper Assessment Tool for
Disability (PAT-D) at baseline and follow-up. Additionally, activities of daily living will
be assessed using the Mobility Assessment Tool - Short Form (MAT-sf) at baseline and
follow-up. This is a novel, computerized tool for self-assessment of functional performance
designed to reduce bias from factors such as age, gender and body image. The Short Form 12
(SF-12) will be used as a generic measure of health related quality of life. The
questionnaire consists of two norm-based composite T-scales, assessing mental health and
physical function. Lastly, mood will be assessed using the 10-item Center for Epidemiologic
Studies Depression Scale (CES-D).
Compliance and satisfaction will be controlled by the use of behavioral strategies including
weight status collection at regular, bi-weekly intervals for both groups. Additionally,
participants randomized to the high protein weight loss group will be asked to provide
information on daily dietary intake and complete a satisfaction survey at the end of
intervention to express thoughts and feelings about following the Medifast 4 & 2 & 1 Plan.
Lastly, 24-hour urine nitrogen will be assessed to ensure differential protein intake by
sending participants home with a container and instructions at baseline and follow up.
Participants will be asked to: (1) void at 8 AM and discard the specimen; (2) collect all
urine including the final specimen voided at the end of the 24-hour collection period (i.e.,
8 AM the next morning); (3) screw the lid on securely. The sample can be stored at room
temperature or refrigerated for up to 14 days and when the sample is returned, it will be
sent to Labcorp for analysis.
Unpublished data collected in older participants undergoing a 6-month weight loss
intervention indicate that it i possible to generate a clinically meaningful 400-meter walk
gait speed difference of at least 0.05 m/s, with a common group standard deviation of 0.19
m/s and a correlation of 0.85 between baseline and 6-month measures. An analysis of
covariance (ANCOVA) analytic approach will be used to fit the randomization effect and
baseline gait speed, then 53 subjects completing the intervention per group will yield 80%
power using a two-sided alternative hypothesis at the 0.05 level of significance. Assuming a
conservative drop-out rate of 15%, there is a 124 participants (n=62/group) enrollment goal.
To facilitate data transfer and preserve records that can be audited, hard copy forms will be
collected. All data will be manually entered within one week of collection into the study
database. The data entry system will protect confidentiality and data security and the use of
text containing identifying information will be avoided. Data will reside on a server in a
Microsoft SQL server database with daily backup.
Regression diagnostics, residual plots, and exploratory analyses will be performed to find
appropriate transformations for all variables to satisfy linearity, homogeneity of variances,
and normality assumptions. Descriptive statistics consisting of frequency tables and
percentages for categorical variables, and means, standard deviations, medians, and ranges
for continuous variables will be tabulated and presented by intervention group and time
point. Exact 95% confidence intervals (CIs) will be provided for the estimated proportions
and approximate 95% CIs for estimated means. The primary outcome of the intervention effect
on fast 400-meter walk gait speed will be analyzed using an ANCOVA model fit with the main
effect of treatment arm and adjusted for baseline values of fast 400-meter walk gait speed.
The primary test will be covariate-adjusted main treatment effect of the weight loss
intervention compared to the control group, and we assume a Type I error rate of 0.05 for the
two-sided alternative hypothesis. Secondary measures of body composition will be analyzed
similarly, using baseline values of the particular body composition measure as a covariate in
the outcome model. Other data including feasibility and compliance data collected in this
study will be used to inform future studies of weight loss in older adults. All statistical
analyses will be conducted assuming intent-to-treat so that participants will remain assigned
to the initial randomization group regardless of treatment adherence, and participants who do
not adhere or discontinue treatment will still be encouraged to provide outcomes data. Our
group has past success in retaining participants by maintaining frequent contact with
individuals who encounter barriers to participation and creatively accommodate and counsel,
as necessary, to encourage the maximum degree of participation. To ensure the results are not
overly influenced by missing data, a multiple imputation sensitivity analysis of the primary
outcome will be performed using both baseline and post-randomization characteristics to
inform the missing data imputation, assuming observations are missing at random.
Human Subjects Protection
Subjects will be recruited using community-based recruitment strategies including mass and
direct mailings and the local newspapers. We will also advertise in the VITAL newsletter
(BG99-559) and participate in community outreach events.
Informed Consent
Written informed consent will be obtained from each subject and consistent with the
procedures of the WFU Institutional Review Board. The study interviewers will explain the
purpose, methods and extent of the study to prospective participants. The potential
participant is asked to read the informed consent form and ask questions. The form is written
in simple easy to understand language. We require study staff to review all of the key
aspects of the study verbally with the potential participants. Staff is provided with a
structured checklist for this purpose. Staff is then required to question potential
participants to ascertain whether s/he has understood the information. Potential participants
who are illiterate or have impaired vision must have the consent read to them, followed by
review of the checklist, opportunity for questions, and discussion. This process will take
place in a quiet, private room in the Sticht Center. A copy of the signed and dated consent
form will be given to participants, and the original document will be placed in subjects'
individual study files, which will be stored in a secure location. In compliance with the
Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Standards for Privacy of
Individually Identifiable Health Information of the Department of Health and Human Services,
we will access personal health information only after obtaining informed consent.
Potential Risks
1. Blood draw. Slight discomfort, bruising, and/or infection at the sight of puncture for
blood drawing, but blood will be drawn only by trained and experienced phlebotomists who
will minimize the discomfort as much as possible.
2. Physical Performance Testing. There is a risk of the participant losing their balance
and falling associated with the physical performance-based testing (e.g., the fast
400-meter walk test, balance tests, rising from a chair, muscle strength and power
testing). In rare instances persons doing the fast 400-meter walk test will experience
leg or chest pain, heart palpitations, shortness of breath. In very rare situations
exercise can result in heart attack or sudden death. We will minimize this risk by: (1)
safely escorting participants to chairs located along the walking course should they
become unsteady; (2) following them at a close distance; and, (3) being at their side
should they need assistance. There is a risk that participants may experience muscle
soreness, strains, pulls, falls or joint injury or discomfort as a result of the
physical performance testing procedures. A warm-up and range of motion practice will be
conducted before maximal strength testing. In addition, if a participant reports pain,
dizziness, lightheadedness or other medical problem during the test, the test will be
terminated.
3. DXA scans. Exposure to radiation from the whole body, anterior-posterior (AP) spine
(L1-L4), and proximal femur DXA (45 mRem total) for baseline, mid-point, and follow-up
scans.
Confidentiality and Privacy
Confidentiality will be protected by collecting only information needed to assess study
outcomes, minimizing to the fullest extent possible the collection of any information that
could directly identify subjects, and maintaining all study information in a secure manner.
To help ensure subject privacy and confidentiality, only a unique study identifier will
appear on the data collection form. Any collected patient identifying information
corresponding to the unique study identifier will be maintained on a separate master log. The
master log will be kept secure, with access limited to designated study personnel. Following
data collection, subject identifying information will be destroyed at the earliest
opportunity (following a minimum of 3 years of record retention per the Wake Forest School of
Medicine IRB policy), consistent with data validation and study design, producing an
anonymous analytical data set. Data access will be limited to study staff, and also to
Medifast Clinical Affairs personnel. Data and records will be kept locked and secured, with
any computer data password protected. No reference to any individual participant will appear
in reports, presentations, or publications that may arise from the study.
Data and Safety Monitoring
The principal investigator will be responsible for the overall monitoring of the data and
safety of study participants. The principal investigator will be assisted by other members of
the study staff, including the study physician, Rebecca Henderson, MD. In addition, all
project related data and safety will be reviewed biannually by the WFUSM's Older Americans
Independence Center's (OAIC) independent Data Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB).
Reporting of Unanticipated Problems, Adverse Events or Deviations Participants will be
queried at bi-weekly intervention sessions for adverse events (AE). Events will be recorded
on AE tracking forms and categorized based on severity (mild/moderate/severe), seriousness
(yes/no), and relatedness to the study intervention (unrelated, possibly, probably, and
definitely). Any unanticipated problems, including serious and unexpected adverse events, as
well as deviations or protocol changes will be promptly reported by the principal
investigator or project manager to the IRB, the WFUSM OAIC DSMB, and Medifast.
Use of biological samples by other investigators
Biological samples may be used by investigators other than the investigators of the current
study under the terms outlined in the informed consent form. The use will be limited to
non-commercial purposes. The names and other personal identifiers of the study participants
will not be sent to any recipients of the blood samples.
Storage and disposal of biological material
Biologic samples will be stored at Wake Forest University Medical Center for up to twenty
years after the end of the trial at which time the samples will be destroyed. All the
specimens will have numerical study IDs with no personal identifiers of the participants.
These are stored under the Pepper Center Repository (IRB#1219).
Inclusion Criteria:
- Age 65-79 years
- BMI=30-40 kg/m2
- Confirmation of self-reported mobility disability, as assessed by phone
screen/clinical staff
- Self-reported sedentary behavior
- Non-impaired cognitive function (MoCA>18)
- Stability of residence for next 2 years
- Willing and able to follow dietary protocol
- Willing to provide informed consent
- Approved for participation by study physician
- Not involved in another behavioral or interventional research study
- Able to provide own transportation to study visits and Intervention
- Not dependent on a cane or walker
- No evidence of clinical depression, eating disorder, or other contraindications for
participation in voluntary weight loss
- English literacy
Exclusion Criteria:
- Weight loss or gain (±5%) in past 6 months
- Prior bariatric surgery
- Multiple food allergies
- Difficulty with hearing/vision that interferes with study participation
- Excessive alcohol use (>14 drinks/week)
- Smoker (>1 cigarette/d within year)
- Insulin-dependent or uncontrolled diabetes (FBG >140 mg/dl)
- Uncontrolled hypertension (BP>160/100 mmHg)
- Abnormal kidney tests (GFR<40, creatinine >2.0)
- Regular use of medications that may influence body weight or composition
- Severe systemic disease (diagnosis of Parkinson's disease, chronic liver disease,
systemic rheumatic condition, gout, thyroid disease, end stage renal disease) or other
systemic diseases/abnormal laboratory values which would preclude participants from
safely participating in the protocol or impair their ability to complete the study
- Severe symptomatic heart disease or cardiovascular procedure within the past 3 months
or history/current diagnosis/signs and symptoms of heart failure, with either reduced
or preserved Left Ventricular ejection fraction
- Cancer requiring treatment in past year, except skin cancers
- Judged unsuitable for the trial for any reason by clinic staff
We found this trial at
1
site
Click here to add this to my saved trials
