Antibiotics Prior to Mini-screw Implant Insertion
Status: | Recruiting |
---|---|
Healthy: | No |
Age Range: | 12 - Any |
Updated: | 9/15/2018 |
Start Date: | August 7, 2018 |
End Date: | October 2019 |
Contact: | Darren P Hallums, DDS |
Email: | darren.hallums@health.slu.edu |
Phone: | (314)977-7783 |
Antibiotic Prophylaxis Prior to the Insertion of Orthodontic Mini-screw Implants: a Randomized Controlled Trial
The investigators plan to use amoxicillin in capsule form, prepared by a pharmacist, for
antibiotic prophylaxis to decrease the failure rate of mini-screw implants temporarily placed
in the palate of patients involved in Phase II orthodontics treatments. The mini-screws will
be 8 mm long 1.7 mm diameter titanium screws manufactured by Forestadent and are commercially
available and currently widely used in orthodontic treatment in both private practice and
educational settings. Since antibiotic prophylaxis is considered the standard of care with
traditional dental implants, the investigators believe that such prophylaxis will decrease
the failure rate of orthodontic mini-screw implants also.
antibiotic prophylaxis to decrease the failure rate of mini-screw implants temporarily placed
in the palate of patients involved in Phase II orthodontics treatments. The mini-screws will
be 8 mm long 1.7 mm diameter titanium screws manufactured by Forestadent and are commercially
available and currently widely used in orthodontic treatment in both private practice and
educational settings. Since antibiotic prophylaxis is considered the standard of care with
traditional dental implants, the investigators believe that such prophylaxis will decrease
the failure rate of orthodontic mini-screw implants also.
Subjects will be selected for the study based on treatment plans for Phase II orthodontics at
Saint Louis University Center for Advanced Dental Education orthodontics program, which
require the use of palatally placed mini-screw implants for anchorage control. If the patient
is at or beyond the age of 18 years, they will be approached about this study. If the patient
is under the age of 18 years, the parent or legal guardian of the patient will be approached.
After the consult is completed, where the treatment plan has been explained and standard
consent forms have been signed, a member of the research team will verbally confirm with the
patient or the patient and parent/guardian that the patient cannot be excluded from the study
based on exclusion criteria from the patient's medical history. Orthodontic treatment at SLU
CADE involves monthly visits to the orthodontic clinic where patients receive orthodontic
treatment, including leveling and aligning of teeth with archwires and fixed appliances on
teeth, space closure, occlusion correction, and finishing and detailing. Mini-screw placement
is not necessary nor included in all treatment plans given at SLU CADE orthodontics. The
possible subjects for the study will patients who will receive mini-screw implants as a
course of their treatment for orthodontic anchorage (standard of care).
Participants will be weighed so that appropriate dosing can be ensured and randomized 1:1 to
receive either and antibiotic (Amoxicillin) or a placebo (glucose) 1 hour prior to mini-screw
insertion (research related). Patients weighing less than 40 kg will be given 50mg/kg. The
Amoxicillin and the placebo (glucose) will be prepared in capsule form by a pharmacist and
made to look identical. The Amoxicillin or placebo will be dispensed at CADE and taken at
CADE 1 hour prior to the procedure. Standard procedure for dispensing Amoxicillin at SLU CADE
is to draw appropriate dosage from the dispensary and provide Amoxicillin to at risk patients
prior to invasive dental procedures, in accordance with prophylaxis guidelines set form by
the American Heart Association. Documentation of dosage and time of dispensing is noted in
the patient record. However, in this study, documentation in the patient dental record will
only reflect that either a placebo or Amoxicillin was given as part of a randomized
controlled trial. Standard of care for orthodontic mini-screw implants includes oral hygiene
instructions and 1 week of oral antibiotic mouth rinse use (.12% Chlorhexidine) and all
participants in this study will follow standard of care in addition to the administration of
either placebo or antibiotic. Randomization between control or experimental group will be
conducted by the Research Chair, Hiroshi Ueno, and the PI will have no knowledge of to which
group subjects are assigned.
Participants will be followed at time of mini-screw placement (T0), 1 month post procedure
(T1), 3 months post-procedure (T2), and 6 months post-procedure (T3). The participant has
standard of care appointments at these time points, so there are not any extra visits for
research purposes. At these appointment, participants will undergo an intra-oral exam to
determine mobility of the mini-screw(s), to check for inflammation at the site of mini-screw
placement, assess oral hygiene at the site of mini-screw placement, and be asked to rate both
their pain and tenderness related to the mini-screw. Pain is defined as spontaneous pain frim
the mini-screw site. Tenderness is defined as pain resulting from palpation of the
mini-screw. Mobility will be determined by placing a small amount of force on the mini-screw
with a cotton plier. The amount of mobility will be assessed as having no mobility (Grade 0),
having between 0mm and 1 mm of mobility (Grade 1), or having more than 1 mm of mobility
(Grade 2). Inflammation will be assessed as having no redness or swelling at the site (Grade
0), having redness only at the site (Grade 1), or having both redness and swelling (Grade 2).
Oral hygiene will be assessed as having no visible plaque at the site (Grade 0), having small
amounts of plaque at the site (Grade 1), or having moderate to large amounts of plaque at the
site (Grade 2). Pain and tenderness will be evaluated separately and will be assessed by
asking the patient to rate their pain level on a scale of 0 to 10, 0 being no pain and 10
being unbearable, excruciating pain. A member of the research team will make these
evaluations at each time point. All five of these would be assessed as part of the standard
of care for mini-screw placement, regardless of participation in the research study or lack
thereof. The only action related to the research that is not standard of care is the
dispensing of either the antibiotic or the placebo at 1 hour prior to mini-screw placement.
Success of the mini-screw will be defined as number of survival with "Mobility Grade 0 or 1"
& "No Pain" & "Inflammation Grade 0 or 1".
Failure of the mini-screw will be immediately determined as failed if the mini-screw is not
present at one of the time points or upon an assessment of Grade 2 mobility. Grade 2 mobility
will result in removal of the mini-screw.
If the mini-screw implants fail, the participants will have the mini-screw removed. It is up
to assigned instructors as to whether or not mini-screws will be replaced. If the mini-screws
will not be replaced, the patient will be removed from the study, but all data collected will
be included in the research.
Standard of Care will be followed in all instances at time points T(0), T(1), T(2) and T(3).
The dependent variable will be success or failure, while the independent variable will be
antibiotic prophylaxis or placebo. Failure will be defined as mobile or lost MSIs, and
success will be defined as stability of the MSIs maintained after 6 months. 8mm long, 1.5 mm
diameter, palatally placed MSIs provided by a single manufacturer (Forestadent) that are
immediately force loaded or delayed in force loading will be included in the study. Data will
be analyzed with SPSS for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Ill). A Chi Square test for
independence will be used to determine association, if any, between the two categorical
variables. This study will establish an alpha of 0.05 and a beta of 0.08322, and to achieve
power of 0.91, a sample size of 100 subjects is the goal for recruiting.
Saint Louis University Center for Advanced Dental Education orthodontics program, which
require the use of palatally placed mini-screw implants for anchorage control. If the patient
is at or beyond the age of 18 years, they will be approached about this study. If the patient
is under the age of 18 years, the parent or legal guardian of the patient will be approached.
After the consult is completed, where the treatment plan has been explained and standard
consent forms have been signed, a member of the research team will verbally confirm with the
patient or the patient and parent/guardian that the patient cannot be excluded from the study
based on exclusion criteria from the patient's medical history. Orthodontic treatment at SLU
CADE involves monthly visits to the orthodontic clinic where patients receive orthodontic
treatment, including leveling and aligning of teeth with archwires and fixed appliances on
teeth, space closure, occlusion correction, and finishing and detailing. Mini-screw placement
is not necessary nor included in all treatment plans given at SLU CADE orthodontics. The
possible subjects for the study will patients who will receive mini-screw implants as a
course of their treatment for orthodontic anchorage (standard of care).
Participants will be weighed so that appropriate dosing can be ensured and randomized 1:1 to
receive either and antibiotic (Amoxicillin) or a placebo (glucose) 1 hour prior to mini-screw
insertion (research related). Patients weighing less than 40 kg will be given 50mg/kg. The
Amoxicillin and the placebo (glucose) will be prepared in capsule form by a pharmacist and
made to look identical. The Amoxicillin or placebo will be dispensed at CADE and taken at
CADE 1 hour prior to the procedure. Standard procedure for dispensing Amoxicillin at SLU CADE
is to draw appropriate dosage from the dispensary and provide Amoxicillin to at risk patients
prior to invasive dental procedures, in accordance with prophylaxis guidelines set form by
the American Heart Association. Documentation of dosage and time of dispensing is noted in
the patient record. However, in this study, documentation in the patient dental record will
only reflect that either a placebo or Amoxicillin was given as part of a randomized
controlled trial. Standard of care for orthodontic mini-screw implants includes oral hygiene
instructions and 1 week of oral antibiotic mouth rinse use (.12% Chlorhexidine) and all
participants in this study will follow standard of care in addition to the administration of
either placebo or antibiotic. Randomization between control or experimental group will be
conducted by the Research Chair, Hiroshi Ueno, and the PI will have no knowledge of to which
group subjects are assigned.
Participants will be followed at time of mini-screw placement (T0), 1 month post procedure
(T1), 3 months post-procedure (T2), and 6 months post-procedure (T3). The participant has
standard of care appointments at these time points, so there are not any extra visits for
research purposes. At these appointment, participants will undergo an intra-oral exam to
determine mobility of the mini-screw(s), to check for inflammation at the site of mini-screw
placement, assess oral hygiene at the site of mini-screw placement, and be asked to rate both
their pain and tenderness related to the mini-screw. Pain is defined as spontaneous pain frim
the mini-screw site. Tenderness is defined as pain resulting from palpation of the
mini-screw. Mobility will be determined by placing a small amount of force on the mini-screw
with a cotton plier. The amount of mobility will be assessed as having no mobility (Grade 0),
having between 0mm and 1 mm of mobility (Grade 1), or having more than 1 mm of mobility
(Grade 2). Inflammation will be assessed as having no redness or swelling at the site (Grade
0), having redness only at the site (Grade 1), or having both redness and swelling (Grade 2).
Oral hygiene will be assessed as having no visible plaque at the site (Grade 0), having small
amounts of plaque at the site (Grade 1), or having moderate to large amounts of plaque at the
site (Grade 2). Pain and tenderness will be evaluated separately and will be assessed by
asking the patient to rate their pain level on a scale of 0 to 10, 0 being no pain and 10
being unbearable, excruciating pain. A member of the research team will make these
evaluations at each time point. All five of these would be assessed as part of the standard
of care for mini-screw placement, regardless of participation in the research study or lack
thereof. The only action related to the research that is not standard of care is the
dispensing of either the antibiotic or the placebo at 1 hour prior to mini-screw placement.
Success of the mini-screw will be defined as number of survival with "Mobility Grade 0 or 1"
& "No Pain" & "Inflammation Grade 0 or 1".
Failure of the mini-screw will be immediately determined as failed if the mini-screw is not
present at one of the time points or upon an assessment of Grade 2 mobility. Grade 2 mobility
will result in removal of the mini-screw.
If the mini-screw implants fail, the participants will have the mini-screw removed. It is up
to assigned instructors as to whether or not mini-screws will be replaced. If the mini-screws
will not be replaced, the patient will be removed from the study, but all data collected will
be included in the research.
Standard of Care will be followed in all instances at time points T(0), T(1), T(2) and T(3).
The dependent variable will be success or failure, while the independent variable will be
antibiotic prophylaxis or placebo. Failure will be defined as mobile or lost MSIs, and
success will be defined as stability of the MSIs maintained after 6 months. 8mm long, 1.5 mm
diameter, palatally placed MSIs provided by a single manufacturer (Forestadent) that are
immediately force loaded or delayed in force loading will be included in the study. Data will
be analyzed with SPSS for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Ill). A Chi Square test for
independence will be used to determine association, if any, between the two categorical
variables. This study will establish an alpha of 0.05 and a beta of 0.08322, and to achieve
power of 0.91, a sample size of 100 subjects is the goal for recruiting.
Inclusion Criteria: Subjects will be selected for the study based on treatment plans for
Phase II orthodontics at SLU CADE orthodontics program, which require the use of palatally
placed mini-screw implants for anchorage control.
Exclusion Criteria:
- Patients with experience in previous MSI placements
- allergy to amoxicillin
- allergy to Beta-lactam based antibiotics
- medical syndrome diagnoses
- psychiatric disorders (ADHD, autism, manic-depressive disorder, etc.)
- a compromised immune system
- impaired or decreased kidney function
- Type I or Type II diabetes
- patients taking Probenicid or Allopurinol
We found this trial at
1
site
3320 Rutger Street
Saint Louis, Missouri 63104
Saint Louis, Missouri 63104
Principal Investigator: Darren P Hallums, DDS
Phone: 314-977-8353
Click here to add this to my saved trials