Early Ultrasound-guided Nerve Block for Painful Hand Injuries in the Emergency Department
| Status: | Completed |
|---|---|
| Conditions: | Hospital, Hospital, Orthopedic |
| Therapuetic Areas: | Orthopedics / Podiatry, Other |
| Healthy: | No |
| Age Range: | 18 - Any |
| Updated: | 10/26/2018 |
| Start Date: | July 1, 2017 |
| End Date: | July 10, 2018 |
This study aims to determine whether early initiation of temporary nerve block therapy
improves patient satisfaction, decreases patient pain and discomfort, decreases the use of
dangerous medications such as narcotics, and frees hospital resources. Hand injuries, such as
blast injuries from fireworks, can be very painful. In the emergency department, providers
generally use narcotic pain medications to control pain, but these have significant side
effects. It is possible that temporary nerve blocks, guided by ultrasound, can be safe and
useful in the emergency department. They have been shown to be effective in several studies
around the country. The goal of this study is to build on the experience of others to
increase the use of US-guided regional nerve blocks as a form of pain management in hand and
distal forearm injuries in the Harborview Medical Center (HMC) emergency department. By
working with a multidisciplinary team, the study investigators hope to use this technique to
decrease narcotic use and improve pain control, and to provide important data for Emergency
Medicine physicians elsewhere who are considering incorporating this nerve block technique
into their practice.
improves patient satisfaction, decreases patient pain and discomfort, decreases the use of
dangerous medications such as narcotics, and frees hospital resources. Hand injuries, such as
blast injuries from fireworks, can be very painful. In the emergency department, providers
generally use narcotic pain medications to control pain, but these have significant side
effects. It is possible that temporary nerve blocks, guided by ultrasound, can be safe and
useful in the emergency department. They have been shown to be effective in several studies
around the country. The goal of this study is to build on the experience of others to
increase the use of US-guided regional nerve blocks as a form of pain management in hand and
distal forearm injuries in the Harborview Medical Center (HMC) emergency department. By
working with a multidisciplinary team, the study investigators hope to use this technique to
decrease narcotic use and improve pain control, and to provide important data for Emergency
Medicine physicians elsewhere who are considering incorporating this nerve block technique
into their practice.
Hand and forearm pain secondary to fracture, laceration, dislocation, infection, and blast
injury is a common issue in the emergency department (ED). Pain control is particularly
important in these patients as they frequently require manipulation of their injured
extremity for suturing, reduction, splinting, or abscess drainage. Pain management has
traditionally centered on the use of parenteral narcotics. These medications can have
significant side effects, especially in the elderly and those with comorbid diseases, and may
not provide sufficient pain control in these cases, specifically in those with opioid
tolerance or gruesome blast injuries. Regional nerve blocks have proven a useful tool in the
management of extremity pain but have been traditionally limited to use by anesthesiologists
in order to limit side effects such as intravascular infiltration and nerve damage. However,
the use of direct visualization with ultrasound (US) can minimize these risks and emergency
medicine (EM) physicians are using nerve blocks with increasing frequency. Recent emergency
medicine literature has been promising with regard to the successful use of US-guided
regional nerve blocks for finger reduction, upper extremity fractures, dislocations, abscess
drainage, and hand blast injuries in the emergency department. In one case series, nerve
blocks were used successfully in pediatric patients and studies measuring feasibility have
found that these blocks can be done in less than ten minutes, and without significant
complications. However, more studies are needed before these blocks become standard of care
in all institutions. Studies that evaluate the use of other pain medications in the setting
of these blocks would be particularly helpful.
Academic institutions are using US-guided nerve blocks with increasing frequency. In a recent
publication 121 academic instructions provided information on usage of this technique. 84% of
programs perform US-guided nerve blocks, most commonly forearm nerve blocks (ulnar, median,
or radial nerves). Nerve block technique is taught via didactic sessions, online resources,
and supervised training. However, most of the programs do not have specific agreements with
other specialty services with regard to performing US-guided nerve blocks in the ED. One
group has successfully created a multidisciplinary approach to treat blast injuries to the
hand which includes EM physicians and surgeons. This team recognized the importance of
surgical evaluation prior to nerve block in blast injuries to assess for risk of compartment
syndrome. No cases of compartment syndrome were reported in this case series and pain control
provided by the nerve block allowed the surgical team to evaluate the extent of injuries,
irrigate the wound thoroughly, and employ temporizing measures such as sutures and splints
while the patient waited for definitive management.
However, this aforementioned study was inherently limited in that it was a feasibility study.
While promising, further work that establishes forearm blocks by ED physicians in the setting
of severe hand injuries as safe and effective can guide us as to whether this mode of pain
management should be standard of care. A major goal of this study will be to provide
important data for emergency physicians when they consider whether or not to include these
blocks into their practice.
To that end, the study investigators present a randomized controlled trial where patients
with blast injuries will be randomized to standard-of-care versus early ultrasound-guided
nerve block as an intervention. Measured outcomes will include pain scores, complications,
and opioid use.
injury is a common issue in the emergency department (ED). Pain control is particularly
important in these patients as they frequently require manipulation of their injured
extremity for suturing, reduction, splinting, or abscess drainage. Pain management has
traditionally centered on the use of parenteral narcotics. These medications can have
significant side effects, especially in the elderly and those with comorbid diseases, and may
not provide sufficient pain control in these cases, specifically in those with opioid
tolerance or gruesome blast injuries. Regional nerve blocks have proven a useful tool in the
management of extremity pain but have been traditionally limited to use by anesthesiologists
in order to limit side effects such as intravascular infiltration and nerve damage. However,
the use of direct visualization with ultrasound (US) can minimize these risks and emergency
medicine (EM) physicians are using nerve blocks with increasing frequency. Recent emergency
medicine literature has been promising with regard to the successful use of US-guided
regional nerve blocks for finger reduction, upper extremity fractures, dislocations, abscess
drainage, and hand blast injuries in the emergency department. In one case series, nerve
blocks were used successfully in pediatric patients and studies measuring feasibility have
found that these blocks can be done in less than ten minutes, and without significant
complications. However, more studies are needed before these blocks become standard of care
in all institutions. Studies that evaluate the use of other pain medications in the setting
of these blocks would be particularly helpful.
Academic institutions are using US-guided nerve blocks with increasing frequency. In a recent
publication 121 academic instructions provided information on usage of this technique. 84% of
programs perform US-guided nerve blocks, most commonly forearm nerve blocks (ulnar, median,
or radial nerves). Nerve block technique is taught via didactic sessions, online resources,
and supervised training. However, most of the programs do not have specific agreements with
other specialty services with regard to performing US-guided nerve blocks in the ED. One
group has successfully created a multidisciplinary approach to treat blast injuries to the
hand which includes EM physicians and surgeons. This team recognized the importance of
surgical evaluation prior to nerve block in blast injuries to assess for risk of compartment
syndrome. No cases of compartment syndrome were reported in this case series and pain control
provided by the nerve block allowed the surgical team to evaluate the extent of injuries,
irrigate the wound thoroughly, and employ temporizing measures such as sutures and splints
while the patient waited for definitive management.
However, this aforementioned study was inherently limited in that it was a feasibility study.
While promising, further work that establishes forearm blocks by ED physicians in the setting
of severe hand injuries as safe and effective can guide us as to whether this mode of pain
management should be standard of care. A major goal of this study will be to provide
important data for emergency physicians when they consider whether or not to include these
blocks into their practice.
To that end, the study investigators present a randomized controlled trial where patients
with blast injuries will be randomized to standard-of-care versus early ultrasound-guided
nerve block as an intervention. Measured outcomes will include pain scores, complications,
and opioid use.
Inclusion Criteria:
- Patient with moderate to severe hand blast injury or other significantly painful hand
or distal forearm injury Also, patients who...
- Are awake and alert
- Are able to endorse or rate their pain
- Require intravenous pain medication for their hand injury
- Are determined to be clinically sober for consent. They will need to be fluent of
speech and able to articulate understanding of the procedure they will undergo and the
study they will enter.
Exclusion Criteria:
Patient's who...
- Require surgical management, within one half hour, for any injury
- Require any emergent care, including resuscitation, the should preclude their regional
pain management
- Are hemodynamically unstable
- Have signs of coagulopathy
- Have clinical features suggestive of compartment syndrome of the forearm, including:
- Tense or firm forearm compartment
- Expanding hematoma
- Regional neurologic deficit (weakness or numbness)
- Have weakness or a sensory deficit in an intact part of their hand or forearm
- Have a vascular injury proximal to the hand
- Are unconscious or otherwise unable to endorse or rate their pain
- Are not deemed clinically sober enough to articulate an understanding of the procedure
they will undergo and the study they will enter.
- Are prisoners
- Are <18 years old
We found this trial at
1
site
Click here to add this to my saved trials
